UK conditions for supporting the war in Gaza

EM Agnew made this Freedom of Information request to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Automatic anti-spam measures are in place for this older request. Please let us know if a further response is expected or if you are having trouble responding.

1 follower

The request was refused by Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office.

Dear Lord Cameron,

My previous Freedom of Information request on this issue, was addressed to former Foreign Secretary James Cleverly MP. I trust that you will be shown this request and that you will have time to respond to it.

The actions of Hamas on the 07 Oct 23 were horrendous. If I remember correctly, the UK and USA governments were quick to warn against making the same horrendous mistakes, which they made immediately after 9/11 2001. Presumably, on or very soon after the 07 Oct 2023, they urgently shared essential lessons with the Israeli government. Those lessons are sure to have stressed the crucial importance, of not allowing rage to undermine the need for the most constructive and robust planning. Only that, could maximise the protection of all Israelis and all Palestinians, provide the most rational means of creating the conditions for a lasting peace and prevent actions which would so very obviously be counterproductive.

If, however, the Israeli government was determined to pursue an all-out war, involving the whole of the Palestinian population, did the UK government state that its support would immediately be withdrawn, if one or more of the following conditions were to be breached and not remedied on demand?:-

(01) existing medical facilities would be protected and/or temporary Nightingale hospitals would urgently be constructed within protected zones within Gaza and provided within ships bordering the Gaza coast;

(02) there would always be adequate supplies of medical equipment, medicines and emergency staff;

(03) no babies, young children, young adults and older people would have limbs amputated without anaesthetics;

(04) no women would undergo caesarean births without anaesthetics;

(05) adequate supplies of food and water would never be denied to anyone for any reason;

(06) no-one would be subjected to psychological and/or physical torture for any reason;

(07) no actions would be taken which most reasonable people would regard as breaches of international law;

(08) no actions would be taken which Lord Neuberger and other UK judges and lawyers have stated would breach Jewish law;

(09) the Israeli government would put an immediate stop to any Israelis obstructing any of the above;

(10) agreement would be reached on the minimum means by which Israel would engage in self defence, so as not to stray unreasonably beyond the boundaries, of what most reasonable people would regard as absolutely necessary.

Points (1) to (10) are:-

(a) framed to enable simple "Yes" or "No" answers to be provided from written evidence held by the UK government;

(b) intended to highlight the importance of so-called civilised countries, demonstrating that they will not be moved from the moral high ground.

Yours sincerely,

John Bradfield

BACKGROUND NOTES

The above have resulted from my previous Freedom of Information request, which was rejected.

That is dated the 20 Oct 2023 and entitled 'How to maximise the protection of all Israelis and Palestinians" and is displayed on this website.

Civil servants in the UK must, according to the Civil Service Code and associated Statutory Guidance, serve the government of the day but must not engage in any activity which would breach any laws. UK civil servants have joined with others in the EU and USA in having issued the statement below. Of particular note is this quote:-
"Israel's military operations have disregarded all important counterterrorism expertise gained since 9/11; and that the operation has not contributed to Israel’s goal of defeating Hamas and instead has strengthened the appeal of Hamas, Hezbollah and other negative actors".

Transatlantic Civil Servants’ Statement on Gaza:
It Is Our Duty To Speak Out
When Our Governments’ Policies Are Wrong

Released February 2, 2024

Declaration of civil servants regarding Gaza:

Recalling that:

We have the duty to respect, protect and uphold our constitutions and international and national legal obligations which our democratically elected executives have committed us to;

We are expected as civil servants to respect, serve and uphold the law while implementing policies, regardless of the political parties in power; that we have done so for our entire careers;

We have been hired to serve, inform and advise our governments/institutions and we have demonstrated professionalism, expertise, and experience that our governments have relied on over the past decades of our service;

We have internally expressed our concerns that the policies of our governments/institutions do not serve our interests and called for alternatives that would better serve national and international security, democracy and freedom; reflect the core principles of western foreign policy; and incorporate lessons learned;

Our professional concerns were overruled by political and ideological considerations;

We are obliged to do everything in our power on behalf of our countries and ourselves to not be complicit in one of the worst human catastrophes of this century; and

We are obliged to warn the publics of our countries, whom we serve, and to act in concert with transnational colleagues.

We publicly reiterate our concerns that:

Israel has shown no boundaries in its military operations in Gaza which has resulted in tens of thousands of preventable civilian deaths; and that the deliberate blocking of aid by Israel has led to a humanitarian catastrophe, putting thousands of civilians at risk of starvation and slow death;

Israel's military operations have not contributed to its goal of releasing all hostages and is putting their well-being, lives and release at risk;

Israel's military operations have disregarded all important counterterrorism expertise gained since 9/11; and that the operation has not contributed to Israel’s goal of defeating Hamas and instead has strengthened the appeal of Hamas, Hezbollah and other negative actors;

The ongoing military operation will be detrimental not just for Israel’s own security but also regional stability; the risk of wider wars is also negatively impacting stated security objectives of our governments;

Our governments have provided the Israeli military operation with public, diplomatic and military support; that this support has been given without real conditions or accountability; and that when faced with humanitarian catastrophe, our governments have failed to call for an immediate ceasefire and an end to blockages of necessary food/water/medicine in Gaza;

Our governments’ current policies weaken their moral standing and undermine their ability to stand up for freedom, justice, and human rights globally and weaken our efforts to rally international support for Ukraine and to counter malign actions by Russia, China and Iran; and
There is a plausible risk that our governments’ policies are contributing to grave violations of international humanitarian law, war crimes and even ethnic cleansing or genocide.

We therefore call on our governments/institutions to:

Stop asserting to the public that there is a strategic and defensible rationale behind the Israeli operation and that supporting it is in our countries’ interests;

Hold Israel, like all actors, accountable to international humanitarian and human rights standards applied elsewhere and to forcefully respond to attacks against civilians, as we are doing in our support to the Ukrainian people; this includes demanding immediate and full implementation of the recent order of the International Court of Justice;

Use all leverage available - including a halt to military support - to secure a lasting ceasefire and full humanitarian access in Gaza and a safe release of all hostages; and

Develop a strategy for lasting peace that includes a secure Palestinian state and guarantees for Israel’s security, so that an attack like 7 October and an offensive on Gaza never happen again.

Coordinated by civil servants in:

European Union institutions and bodies
The Netherlands
United States

Also endorsed by civil servants in:

Belgium
Denmark
Finland
France
Germany
Italy
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
United Kingdom

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

The Information rights Unit are not able to respond to queries on the
issues mentioned below. Emails about these issues will be deleted without
response. Please note the relevant guidance and redirect your query
accordingly.

Afghanistan related enquiries

The UK evacuation operation has now ceased. The security situation in
Afghanistan remains extremely volatile. There is an ongoing and high
threat of terrorist attack. The potential for terrorist attacks,
particularly around Kabul airport, remains very high. British nationals
remaining in Afghanistan need to consider carefully the risks should they
attempt to leave by any route. We advise against all travel to
Afghanistan. We continue to closely monitor events in Afghanistan. Please
check our travel advice for our latest advice for British nationals, and
subscribe for updates.

The British Embassy in Kabul has suspended in-country operations. All UK
diplomatic and consular staff have been temporarily withdrawn. The ability
to provide consular support to British nationals is extremely limited and
is being provided virtually. If you are a British national in Afghanistan
and need to speak to a consular officer call the FCDO on +441908 516666
(or 01908 516666 in the UK). The FCDO cannot offer advice on the safety of
travelling to any alternative departure point.

British nationals who remain in Afghanistan are strongly encouraged to
[2]register their presence in order to receive important updates. This
will enable us to validate the numbers of British nationals seeking
assistance, and to provide essential information to British nationals that
remain in Afghanistan, when it becomes available.

If you are an Afghan national and are eligible or have been approved for
assistance under the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (ARAP),there
is more information here:
[3]https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...

If you are a non-British national in Afghanistan, or are the family member
of a non-British national in Afghanistan, and in need of assistance,
please see
[4]https://www.gov.uk/guidance/support-for-...
or call +44 2475 389 980 (or 02475 389 980 in the UK).

Current and former locally employed UK government staff, ie those who were
employed directly by the UK government, not through a third party, should
apply to ARAP following this link:
[5]https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio....

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Contact the Legalisation Office if you need an update on an application or
if you have a general enquiry: [9][email address], Telephone:
03700 00 22 44
Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, [10]Find out about call charges

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

If you require travel advice for your destination country, please visit
the [13]Travel Advice pages, which contain the latest information on
coronavirus, safety and security, entry requirements and areas where the
FCDO advises against travel. You can also subscribe to travel advice
email alerts for your destination and monitor the FCDO coronavirus travel
advice page. You can follow FCDO Travel social media channels
on [14]Twitter, [15]Facebook and [16]Instagram. If you have a question
about the advice or a topic that is not covered, [17]please submit an
enquiry.

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

Dear Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office civil servants,

My second Freedom of Information request, is addressed to the current Foreign Secretary Lord Cameron.

However, this follow-up message dated the 02 March 2024 is solely for civil servants, in view of what follows.

In the automated acknowledgement dated the 03 February 2024 this is stated:-
"Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response".

My understanding is, that FCDO civil servants have a legal obligation under the Civil Service Code and related Statutory Guidance, to comply with all laws.

Does the above quote mean, that AS A MATTER OF ROUTINE, civil servants do not comply with:-
(a) domestic law in connection with Freedom of Information requests and/or
(b) some or all international laws regarding the protection of all Israelis and/or all Palestinians and/or people in other parts of the world?

Regarding (b) I must draw your attention to details on international law, within my Freedom of Information request entitled, 'Transatlantic Civil Servants’ Statement on Gaza: It Is Our Duty To Speak Out When Our Governments’ Policies Are Wrong', which was released on the 02 February 2024.

Yours faithfully,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

OFFICIAL

Dear Mr Bradfield,

Thankyou for your email.

The automated acknowledgement serves to assist people contacting the FCDO as we regularly receive emails that are not for the Information Rights Unit. Due to the large volume of requests received we are unable to provide updates individually within the initial 20 working days.

Kind Regards

Information Rights Unit

OFFICIAL

show quoted sections

Dear Information Rights Unit staff,

Thank you for your response today.

I asked whether, AS A MATTER OF ROUTINE, civil servants do not comply with:-
(a) domestic law in connection with Freedom of Information requests and/or
(b) some or all international laws regarding the protection of all Israelis and/or all Palestinians and/or people in other parts of the world?

As mentioned, it is my understanding, that FCDO civil servants have a legal obligation under the Civil Service Code and related Statutory Guidance, to comply with all laws.

I must assume, from what is not said in the response today that, "AS A MATTER OR ROUTINE", they do not comply with all laws and in addition, they must be doing so with routine and implicitly guaranteed impunity.

I must also assume, that the current position is acceptable to all civil servants, including those at the highest levels, who appear to be condoning the ways things are.

Yours faithfully,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

FCDO Departmental Response TO2024 02996 1.pdf

94K Download View as HTML

Dear John Bradfield,

Thank you for your recent correspondence of 3rd February to the Foreign,
Commonwealth and Development Office. Please see the attached reply.

Yours sincerely,

Ministerial and Treat Official Correspondence Team
Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only. All messages sent and
received by the FCDO may be monitored in line with relevant UK
legislation.

Please do not respond to this email address, as replies are routed to an
unmonitored mailbox. If you require additional information please contact
[1][email address]

References

Visible links
1. mailto:[email address]

OFFICIAL

Dear John Bradfield,

Thank you for your email to the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
(FCDO).

Freedom of Information (FOI) requests are requests for recorded
information. We aim to respond to FOI requests within 20 working days
where possible.

You may find the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) guidance here
useful: [1]How to access information from a public authority | ICO

If you have questions about particular FCDO policies that do not ask for
recorded information or specific documents, those requests would not be
handled under the FOI Act.

You should have received a response yesterday to your email of 5 ^
February from the relevant FCDO team, laying out the UK Government’s
position on Israel and Gaza.

Yours sincerely,

Information Rights Unit

OFFICIAL

show quoted sections

Dear Lord Cameron,

I am writing to request an internal review of the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office's handling of my FOI request 'UK conditions for supporting the war in Gaza'.

I posed 10 specific points, asking if each has been a condition for supporting the war in Gaza.

There must be written and permanently recorded information on each of the 10 specific points, unless one or more,
(a) were not discussed or negotiated and therefore not recorded or
(b) were discussed and were or were not made conditions for supporting the intensive and relentless war but in either case, recorded information must exist.

If I need to submit a third Freedom of Information request, I will ask for evidence of how the government defines terrorism and whether that is or is not used, to encompass the relentless mass murder of babies and young children and subjecting those who are still alive, to being deprived of adequate and safe food and water and a very large proportion, having to have horrendous amputations and other radical surgeries, without anaesthetics. Those and other points raised, are based on what was initially and subsequently agreed by the UK government, would be adequate means of defence and protection for all Israelis and all Palestinians. Regarding the former, they have been provided with far more than adequate means of defence. Regarding that latter, it appears that the UK government may never have offered innocent babies and young children, adequate means of defence and stated exactly how that would be provided.

Yours sincerely,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

OFFICIAL

Dear John Bradfield,

Thank you for your email to the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
(FCDO).

As outlined in our email of 6 March, Freedom of Information (FOI) requests
are requests for recorded information. We aim to respond to FOI requests
within 20 working days where possible.

You may find the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) guidance here
useful: [1]How to access information from a public authority | ICO

If you have questions about particular FCDO policies that do not ask for
recorded information or specific documents, those requests would not be
handled under the FOI Act.

The previous request you submitted was therefore not handled under the FOI
Act and you would have received a response from the relevant FCDO team,
laying out the UK Government’s position on Israel and Gaza. We are unable
to accept your request for an Internal Review when the original enquiry
was not handled as an FOI request.

Yours sincerely,

Information Rights Unit

OFFICIAL

From: EM Agnew <[2][FOI #1080412 email]>
Sent: Thursday, March 7, 2024 1:10 PM
To: Information Rights <[3][FCDO request email]>
Subject: Internal review of Freedom of Information request - UK conditions
for supporting the war in Gaza

[You don't often get email from
[4][FOI #1080412 email]. Learn why this is
important at [5]https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentific... ]

Dear Lord Cameron,

I am writing to request an internal review of the Foreign, Commonwealth &
Development Office's handling of my FOI request 'UK conditions for
supporting the war in Gaza'.

I posed 10 specific points, asking if each has been a condition for
supporting the war in Gaza.

There must be written and permanently recorded information on each of the
10 specific points, unless one or more,

(a) were not discussed or negotiated and therefore not recorded or

(b) were discussed and were or were not made conditions for supporting
the intensive and relentless war but in either case, recorded information
must exist.

If I need to submit a third Freedom of Information request, I will ask for
evidence of how the government defines terrorism and whether that is or is
not used, to encompass the relentless mass murder of babies and young
children and subjecting those who are still alive, to being deprived of
adequate and safe food and water and a very large proportion, having to
have horrendous amputations and other radical surgeries, without
anaesthetics. Those and other points raised, are based on what was
initially and subsequently agreed by the UK government, would be adequate
means of defence and protection for all Israelis and all Palestinians.
Regarding the former, they have been provided with far more than adequate
means of defence. Regarding that latter, it appears that the UK government
may never have offered innocent babies and young children, adequate means
of defence and stated exactly how that would be provided.

Yours sincerely,

John Bradfield

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Please use this email address for all replies to this request:

[6][FOI #1080412 email]

Disclaimer: This message and any reply that you make will be published on
the internet. Our privacy and copyright policies:

[7]https://eur03.safelinks.protection.outlo...

For more detailed guidance on safely disclosing information, read the
latest advice from the ICO:

[8]https://eur03.safelinks.protection.outlo...

[9]https://eur03.safelinks.protection.outlo...

Please note that in some cases publication of requests and responses will
be delayed.

If you find this service useful as an FOI officer, please ask your web
manager to link to us from your organisation's FOI page.

show quoted sections

Dear Lord Cameron,

Please let me know, whether my this,
my second FoI request on the war in and beyond Gaza:-
(a) has or has not been rejected and
(b) if not rejected, when a decision can be expected on an internal review.

Yours sincerely,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

OFFICIAL - FOR PUBLIC RELEASE

Dear Mr Bradfield,

As previously explained, your previous emails have not been considered FOI requests as they did not ask for recorded information. The relevant teams replied stating government policy. You cannot request an Internal Review when it was not an FOI request.

If you wish to submit an FOI request for specific recorded information, you may wish to visit the ICO page referenced below for guidance on what is a valid FOI request. We will then handle as appropriate.

Kind Regards,

Information Rights Unit

OFFICIAL - FOR PUBLIC RELEASE

show quoted sections

Dear Lord Cameron,

My FoI request is dated the 03 Feb 2024.

Under point (a) I have clearly requested information,
"from WRITTEN EVIDENCE held by the UK government".

My FoI request has been rejected, because of the erroneous conclusion, that I have not asked for recorded information.

For that reason, my request for an internal review has been rejected.

As I am entirely confident, that a request for "WRITTEN EVIDENCE" is a request for "recorded information", I am referring the matter to the Information Commissioner's Office.

Yours sincerely,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

Dear Lord Cameron,

The ICO has received my complaint.

The automated response, appears to state that I must send you a copy.

Below, is only my covering letter to the ICO.. All other details are displayed above on this website.

Yours sincerely,

John Bradfield
__________________________________________________________

Covering letter to ICO staff

I have submitted these two separate FoIs to the Foreign Office:-
'How to maximise the protection of all Israelis and Palestinians', dated 20 Oct 2023
'UK conditions for supporting the war in Gaza', dated 03 Feb 2024

Full details are displayed [above on this website], where I state that it is likely to be correct, that my first FoI could be rejected, because of the complexities and cost.

However, it seems that my second FoI has been rejected because,
(a) my first was rejected and
(b) it keeps being falsely asserted, that I had not asked for evidence from "written" information..

On the 19 Mar 2024 the reply states,
"We are unable to accept your request for an Internal Review when the original enquiry was not handled as an FOI request".

On the 21 Mar 2024 this was stated as you will see:-
"As previously explained, your previous emails have not been considered FOI requests as they did not ask for recorded information. The relevant teams replied stating government policy. You cannot request an Internal Review when it was not an FOI request".

As proven [above on this website], I had made very explicit, with both my first and second FoI requests, that I was asking for evidence from "written" information.

I made that very clear again, when I wrote back today (13 Apr 2023).

I didn't remember to question, whether an internal review can be rejected, because a previous FoI was rejected.

I am assuming that you will only consider my second FoI..

However, I have also displayed my first FoI., in case the context may be significant.

All details are displayed, other than the several lengthy and irrelevant automated acknowledgements, which are sent to everyone.

Highlights in bold red font below are to assist with your task, in finding key points.

Yours faithfully,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

Dear Lord Cameron,

I have received a reply from the Information Commissioner's Office, suggesting how I could alter the wording of this, my second FoI request about the war in Gaza.

As the ICO suggestion appears little or no different to what I have submitted, I have written back to seek clarification.

I have reaffirmed, that I am sure this FoI request, does meet the basic legal rules, to be accepted as legally valid.

However, even if it could be rejected for any pedantic or technical reason, the government is not legally prevented from responding in full to my request, on this incredibly serious matter.

Regarding what may or may not be breaches of international law, it has long been recognised in English law, that the "appearance" of a situation, can be more important than what may be happening. Applying that legal principle, no reasonable person and no reasonable government, needs to wait years, for any courts to issue what of necessity require EMERGENCY judgments, to know whether AVOIDABLE and relentlessly psychopathic and sadistic actions must be stopped, whether in times of peace or war.

Would any UK politicians stand by dithering, if their babies and young children, were being relentlessly forced to have amputations and other radical surgeries without general or even local anaesthetics? Would they need to discuss whether or not, that meets a clear definition of terrorism and/or torture?

Our intelligence service must have warned our government, about exactly how the CURRENT Israeli government would INEVITABLY respond, immediately after the horrors of 07 October 2023. Consequently, it was known, that rage would undermine and continue to undermine, the need for the most constructive and robust planning.

It has long had a commitment to the Dahiya doctrine. That means it had a predetermined intention to destroy the maximum amount of homes and infrastructure, including hospitals and inflict the maximum amount of harm on the maximum number of Palestinian children and others. The intention of that doctrine is to ensure, that it will take a very long time for those who survive, to rebuild their homes and begin to recover psychologically. That doctrine is both counterproductive and fatalistic. It is a commitment to endless wars and in conflict with the very purpose of having international laws.

As far as I am aware, our government has never brought together from around the world, intellectuals with the most creative minds, to examine all possible alternatives to relentless war or how to minimise the terrorism of war. It appears, that only minimal lip service has been paid to learning necessary lessons from 9/11.

Does our government have a credible and robust strategy, for minimising wars and maximising peace, to protect all Israelis, all Palestinians and all other peoples around the world? If such a strategy exists, the fine details should be blazoned across our news media and the internet.

Yours sincerely,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here:
[7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

Dear John Bradfield

Thank you for your FOI request under the Freedom of Information Act 2000.

We received your request on 15th May. It has been assigned a unique
reference number FOI2024/14124. We aim to respond by 13th June.

Yours sincerely,

Information Rights Unit

Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office

Dear Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Ministers and civil servants,

I received very helpful information from the Information Commissioner's Office. However, having given considerable thought to the horrendous issues, regarding Israel and Palestine, I fear my own government prior to the recent general election, had relentlessly refused to comply with the letter and spirit of domestic and international law. That revealed a lack of ethical and intellectual credibility, which made it futile to pursue such requests for information. As I may have reiterated before, no law stands in the way of being honest, open and transparent, in connection with many or most if not all of the issues which I have raised. In a separate matter, I have proven with evidence from case law, that our own Ministry of Justice, which is responsible for our legal system and our courts, deliberately (sic) misled numerous judges right up to the UK Supreme Court, not least to conceal ongoing decision making which is unlawful. Hopefully, the new government will raise standards to at least a minimum level.

In future, unless there is adherence to the very sound legal principles in the Civil Service Code and statutory Guidance, I may simply abandon FoI requests, rather than apply for internal reviews.

Yours faithfully,

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here: [7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Contact the Legalisation Office if you need an update on an application or
if you have a general enquiry: [9][email address], Telephone: 03700 00 22
44
Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, [10]Find out about call charges

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

FOI2024 14124 Response Letter.pdf

162K Download View as HTML

Dear John Bradfield,

I am writing in response to your Freedom of Information request
FOI2024/14124, received 15th May. Please find our response attached.

Yours sincerely,

Information Rights Unit

Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office

NOTE FOR WHAT DO THEY KNOW

I am unable to say, that the requested information has been received.

I am also unable to say, that some information has been received which is directly relevant.

I am able to say, that I fear it is not possible to obtain straight answers to straight questions.

There needs to be another option to tick, such as 'Avoidance' or 'Subterfuge'.

Consequently, I have decided to mark this FoI as having been refused.

If any readers think my response is unreasonable, please do provide an explanation.

Horrendous life and death issues require urgent and crystal clear responses.

I fear that I, along with other UK citizens, am being made responsible for war crimes and innumerable breaches of international law, with no obvious remedies.

John Bradfield

Thank you for contacting the FCDO Information Rights Unit (IRU).

PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING ADVICE

Once we have officially accepted your request, we are unable to provide
progress updates within the initial 20 working day deadline for response.

Please do not send multiple emails about the same enquiry, as this is
likely to cause a delay in our response time.

Should you need assistance in making or refining your request you may wish
to consult the gov.uk guide on [1]How to make a Freedom of Information
(FOI) request

Afghanistan related enquiries

Further information on the ARAP scheme can be found here:
[6]https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2021...

If you have already applied for ARAP, and would like an update on your
application, please re-send your query here: [7][email address]

Non-Afghanistan related Consular Assistance for British Nationals

If you are a British national seeking urgent consular assistance, please
call the Consular Assistance Team on 020 7008 5000 (or +44 20 7008
5000).

ATAS Certificates

Email [8][email address] if you have a query about your application. We
are unable to reply to any query on an application.

Legalisation

Contact the Legalisation Office if you need an update on an application or
if you have a general enquiry: [9][email address], Telephone: 03700 00 22
44
Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, [10]Find out about call charges

Visas

Please see guidance on [11]Applying for a visa to come to the UK or
contact [12]UK Visas and immigration for help.

Travel Advice

This email is intended for the addressee(s) only: All messages sent and
received by the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office may be
monitored in line with relevant [18]UK legislation

References

1 follower

Help us protect your right to hold public authorities to account. Donate and support our work.

Donate Now

WhatDoTheyKnow

UK conditions for supporting the war in Gaza

1 Attachment

1 Attachment

We work to defend the right to FOI for everyone

Act on what you've learnt

Requests like this

FCDO crisis management

Briefing notes

Intranet Details and Financial Commitment for the Past Five Years

How to maximise the protection of all Israelis and Palestinians

Validity of evidence from Israel that Hamas had infiltrated UNWRA that lead to the decision for the UK to pause funding for UNWRA

International Citizen Service (ICS)

Reports on West Papua Independence Movements 2015 - 2024

Spending on overseas PR agencies

CCTV Systems

Contacts withe the Chagos community

WhatDoTheyKnow