Dear National Archives,

The file HO 144/22520, relating to the Gretna (or Quintinshill) rail disaster of 1915, has been closed for 100 years until 1 January 2017.

Despite the opening in recent years at the Scottish National Archives of previously classified documents concerning the disaster – the worst in the history of Britain's railways – HO 144/22520, retained at The National Archives in Kew, remains unavailable for public inspection, singularly classified under the 100-year rule.

There is considerable, and understandable, public interest across the UK, and especially within Scotland, in this accident, its causes and aftermath – interest which has naturally intensified as the 100th anniversary in 2015 approaches.

This interest clearly is not served by the continuing retention of HO 144/22520 as a 'closed' document and, in my submission, It is hard to see why this remains the case.

An event which occurred during the First World War can surely no longer pose any kind of threat to national security a century on, even if it was deemed to have done so at the time.

None of the individuals involved, in any way, in the accident are alive today. Release of the 'closed' documentation cannot possibly threaten their reputation, status or safety today.

However, in my view their families – both those of the many victims of the tragedy and also those of the two signalmen held wholly responsible for it – deserve to learn the full details of what happened, both during and after the event.

I feel that this is a right which should be extended to the British public as a whole in view of the unparalleled severity of the five-train collision and its effect on the nation.

The file's official release date is just five years away. I submit that opening it now for public inspection will have no material adverse affect on the nation or any living person.

This was a major historical event. It is surely time the Government and its agencies provided citizens with all the relevant facts.

Therefore, my request is for the file's status at TNA to be reviewed so that its classification as 'closed' documentation can be reversed and the contents can be opened.

Yours faithfully,

Adrian Searle

foienquiry, National Archives

Dear Mr Searle,

Thank you for your enquiry on 21 February 2012 regarding a review of the closure status of the following file:

HO 144/22520 - CORONERS AND INQUESTS: Deaths and injuries occurring in districts other than that in which the inquest is held: duplicate committals for trial in coroner's area and that in which event took place
- CRIMINAL CASES: Gretna railway disaster: duplicate committal of signalman by the Coroner in Carlisle and the Scottish authorities.

We are pleased to tell you that, in consultation with the Home Office, it has been decided that this document may now be made available at The National Archives, Kew. The file can be ordered and viewed at the National Archives from 24 March 2012.

Under the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act 2000, and the Environmental Information Regulations, 2004, you have the right to:
• know whether we hold the information you require
• be provided with that information

There are various ways for you to access the information you want.

You are welcome to visit us - we can help you to do the search yourself, and admission is free. Please visit our website for information regarding our opening times

Please note we are open five days a week (Tuesday to Saturday).

You may use our online Document Copying Service,

You may wish to use our paid search service to identify specific parts with this document. We will aim to provide you with the information you require, and to provide a prompt and professional service. H.M. Treasury requires recovery of the full cost of providing the service. We will reply to your request within 20 working days (email: [email address]).

There are also many independent researchers whom you can hire to carry out research for you. These researchers may charge significantly less than our ‘full cost recovery’ service. Lists of researchers are available at our web site (

If you visit us, you will need a Reader's Ticket to look at original documents. To obtain a reader's ticket you must bring two documents with you – one to prove your identity (which must have a valid signature) and one to prove your address, or school if you are a student. Please be aware that internet printouts or online statements are not accepted as proof of address. For further information please visit

If you are a citizen of any other country, please bring your passport or national identity card. If you do not have this identification, please ring us on 020 8392 5200 before you visit. Please allow time at the beginning of your visit for familiarisation with our procedures.

The information you have been supplied with may contain personal information about another person that falls within the scope of the Data Protection Act 1998. The Data Protection Act regulates the processing of information relating to identifiable living individuals and this includes the use, disclosure or publication of such information. You are therefore reminded that your use of this information must comply with the terms of this Act. For more information about the Data Protection Act please see the website of the Information Commissioner's Office (

If you are dissatisfied with any aspect of our response to your request for information and/or wish to appeal against information being withheld from you please send full details within two calendar months of the date of this letter to:

The Quality Manager
Public Services Development Unit
The National Archives
Kew, Richmond
Surrey TW9 4DU
Email: [email address]

Please mark your complaint clearly. You have the right to ask the Information Commissioner (ICO) to investigate any aspect of your complaint. Please note that the ICO is likely to expect internal complaints procedures to have been exhausted before beginning his investigation.

Yours sincerely

Poppy Groves

Freedom of Information Researcher
Information Management and Practice Department
The National Archives

If you would like to contact us again regarding
this request, please contact the helpdesk:

via e-mail: By replying to this e-mail
or (020 8876 3444)
Remember to quote your call reference number: F0030557 in any
correspondence, as this will assist us in providing you with a
quick response.

Please don't print this e-mail unless you really need to.

show quoted sections

Looking for an EU Authority?

You can request documents directly from EU Institutions at our sister site . Find out more .