Dear Humberside Police,
The schedule of non-sensitive unused material is linked to a case in which witnesses were accused of producing false statements.
Note, an image (item 7) obtained presumably from a photo taken by a mobile phone was not considered relevant to the case and categorised as "Clearly Not Disclosable" (CND). The evidence might reasonably have been considered capable of undermining the case for the prosecution or of assisting the accused’s case if the image showed that the distance between the witness and defendant was so great that the account could not reasonably have been relied on. It might even have proved impossible to have verified events with the degree of detail described by the witness and would in that case have confirmed that the witness had knowingly made a false statement.
Note also that CCTV footage (item 6) believed to relate to seven cameras covering the relevant area (see links), was not considered relevant to the case and categorised as CND. It is unlikely with such extensive coverage of the relevant area by CCTV that there would be nothing of relevance to the case.
In accordance with the Crown Prosecution Service's continuing duty to consider and review disclosure under the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996 (CPIA), what further disclosure (if any) was required of Humberside police as a result of the exhibit schedule?
In the light of systemic failures to disclose police evidence being discovered and reported in national press, are cases like this being reviewed to identify miscarriages of justice?
Thank you for your request for information. If you are requesting
information under the Freedom of Information Act or the Environmental
Information Regulations you will receive a response within the statutory
20 working days.
We aim to respond to any other enquiries within 20 working days. Further
information on requesting information can be found on this link.
Internet Email should not be treated as a secure means of communication.
To ensure regulatory compliance Humberside Police monitors all Internet
Email activity and content. This communication is intended for the
addressee(s) only. Unauthorised use or disclosure of the content may be
unlawful. If you are not a named addressee, you must not disclose, copy,
print, or in any other way use or rely on the data contained in this
transmission. If received in error you should notify the sender
immediately and delete this Email Humberside Police routinely checks
e-mails for computer viruses. However addressees are advised to conduct
their own virus checks of all e-mails, & any attachments). Opinions
expressed in this document may not be official policy. Thank you for your
co-operation. Humberside Police