Barnsley Local Plan - Stage 3 Hearing Statements

John Earnshaw made this Freedom of Information request to Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council

This request has been closed to new correspondence from the public body. Contact us if you think it ought be re-opened.

Response to this request is long overdue. By law, under all circumstances, Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council should have responded by now (details). You can complain by requesting an internal review.

Dear Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council,

Further to my earlier FOI request on 5th October 2017, concerning the Barnsley Local Plan, Timeline of Examination Events - website pages down time in September 2017 - something has now occurred, which is closely related, hence my new request for this new information.

I would like to know precise details of dates and times and backed up and justified by an official paper trail and/or receipts of when all the Stage 3 Hearing Statements were posted on to the Hearing Statements web page of the Barnsley Local Plan.

LINK TO WEB PAGE - https://www.barnsley.gov.uk/services/pla...

IF POSSIBLE I WOULD LIKE THE FULL LIST OF ACTUAL HEARING STATEMENT DETAILS REQUIRED:

IF NOT POSSIBLE FOR THE FULL LIST TO BE SUPPLIED - THEN COULD YOU KINDLY MANAGE PAGES - 6, 7, 8, and 9 as page 10 is blank?

Page 1

ST3001 - BMBC
ST3001-01 - BMBC Hearing Statement MM10
ST3001-02 - BMBC Hearing Statement MM11
ST3001-03 - BMBC Hearing Statement MM12
ST3001-04 - BMBC Hearing Statement MM13
ST3001-05 - BMBC Hearing Statement MM14
ST3001-06 - BMBC Hearing Statement MM15

ST3002 - Adam Jackson - Lichfields - Duchy Homes
ST3002-01 - Adam Jackson - Lichfields - Duchy Homes - Hearing Statement MM12

ST3003 - Aisling Kelly - Lichfields - Phil & Jill Mullins
ST3003-01 - Aisling Kelly - Lichfields - Phil & Jill Mullins - Hearing Statement MM12
ST3003-02 - Aisling Kelly - Lichfields - Phil & Jill Mullins - Hearing Statement MM14

Page 2

ST3004 - Bernard Greep - Peter Brett Associates – Yorkshire Land Limited
ST3004-01 - Bernard Greep - PBA - Yorkshire Land - Hearing Statement MM12 +14

ST3005 - Bradley Stankler - Bradley Stankler Planning - Penrose Family
ST3005-01 - Bradley Stankler - Penrose Family – Hearing Statement MM12

ST3006 - Brian Heathcote
ST3006-01 - Brian Heathcote - Hearing Statement MM10, 12, 13 +14

ST3007 - Charlotte Stainton - Stainton Planning - Ackroyd & Abbott
ST3007-01 - Stainton Planning - Ackroyd & Abbott – Hearing Statement MM12

ST3008 - Chris Martin - Barton Willmore - Persimmon Homes
ST3008-01 - Chris Martin - Barton Willmore - Persimmon Homes - Hearing Statement MM12
ST3008-02 - Chris Martin - Barton Willmore - Persimmon Homes - Hearing Statement MM14

Page 3

ST3009 - Community Action Penistone
ST3009-01 - Community Action Penistone - Hearing Statement MM12
ST3009-02 - Community Action Penistone - Hearing Statement MM12 - Site H81
ST3009-03 - Community Action Penistone - Hearing Statement MM12 - Site H82
ST3009-04 - Community Action Penistone - Hearing Statement MM12 - Site AC34
ST3009-05 - Community Action Penistone - Hearing Statement MM12 - Site H25
ST3009-Ap1 - Community Action Penistone - Pictures H81
ST3009-Ap2 - Community Action Penistone Pictures H82

ST3010 - David Barker - Evolution Town Planning - Rockley + Wentworth Trustees
ST3010-01 - Evolution Planning - Wentworth Est. Hearing Statement MM12
ST3010-02 - Evolution Planning - Rockley Est. – Hearing Statement MM12

ST3011 - Emma Ridley - Pegasus - Mr D. Smith
ST3011-01 - Emma Ridley - Pegasus - Mr D. Smith - Hearing Statement MM12

ST3012 - Eric Illsley
ST3012-01 - Eric Illsley - Hearing Statement MM13

Page 4

ST3013 - Gary Salter
ST3013-01 - Gary Salter - Hearing Statement MM 10
ST3013-02 - Gary Salter - Hearing Statement MM 12
ST3013-03 - Gary Salter - Hearing Statement MM 13
ST3013-04 - Gary Salter - Hearing Statement MM 14

ST3014 - Graham Northern - DLP - Hornes Properties
ST3014-01 - Graham Northern - DLP - Hornes Properties - Hearing Statement MM12

ST3015 - Graham Northern - DLP - Mr and Mrs Senior
ST3015-01 - Graham Northern - DLP - Mr and Mrs Seniors - Hearing Statement MM12

ST3016 - Graham Northern - DLP - Taylor Wimpey
ST3016-01 - Graham Northern - DLP - Taylor Wimpey - Hearing Statement MM12

ST3017 - Helen Howie - Berrys - Cambridge & Dryden
ST3017-01 - Helen Howie - Berrys - Cambidge and Dryden Hearing Statement MM12
ST3017-02 - Helen Howie - Berrys - Cambidge and Dryden Hearing Statement MM14

Page 5

ST3018 - James Hobson - White Young Green - Goldthorpe Developments, Hoyland Developments & Fitzwilliam Estates
ST3018-01 - James Hobson - WYG – Hearing Statement MM10
ST3018-02- James Hobson - WYG - Hearing Statement MM12

ST3019 - Janet Hodson - JVH Town Planning - Mr & Mrs Waldron
ST3019-01 - Janet Hodson - JVH Town Planning - Mr & Mrs Waldron – Hearing Statement MM12

ST3020 - Janet Hodson - JVH Town Planning - Pepper & Stockil
ST3020-01 - Janet Hodson - JVH Town Planning - Pepper & Stockil – Hearing Statement MM12

ST3021 - Jeremy Williams - ID Planning -Rula Developments
ST3021-01 - Jeremy Williams - ID Planning - Rula Developments - MM10
ST3021-Ap1 - Site Location Plan
ST3021-Ap2 - Sowell Pond LWS Boundary Amendment
ST3021-Ap3 - Indicative Site Layout Plan
ST3021-Ap4a - Great Crested Newt Survey
ST3021-Ap4b - Bat Report
ST3021-Ap4c - Botanical Appraisal
ST3021-Ap4d - Ecological Appraisal
ST3021-Ap5a - Arboriculture Impact Assessment V2
ST3021-Ap5b - Existing Trees on Site
ST3021-Ap5c - Tree Constraints Plan

Page 6

ST3022 - John Earnshaw
ST3022-01 - John Earnshaw - Hearing Statement MM13

ST3023 - Katrina Hulse - Peacock & Smith - Sterling Capitol
ST3023-01 - Katrina Hulse - Peacock & Smith - Sterling Capitol - Hearing Statement MM10

ST3024 - Keep it Green
ST3024-01 - Keep it Green - Hearing Statement MM10
ST3024-02 - Keep it Green - Hearing Statement MM12
ST3024-03 - Keep it Green - Hearing Statement MM13

ST3025 - Lewis Evans - Turley - Hargreaves Services Ltd
ST3025-01 - Lewis Evans - Turley - Hargreaves Services – Hearing Statement MM14

ST3026 - Luke Herring - Johnson Mowat - Elmhirst Family
ST3026-01 - Luke Herring - Johnson Mowat - Elmhirst Family - Hearing Statement MM12

Page 7

ST3027 - Luke Herring- Johnson Mowat - Pipestone Ltd
ST3027-01- Luke Herring - Johnson Mowat - Pipestone Ltd - Hearing Statement MM12

ST3028 - Oliver Freer - Savills - U & I Group
ST3028-01 - Oliver Freer - Savills - U and I Group – Hearing Statement MM10

ST3029 - Paul Butler - PB Planning - Duchy Homes
ST3029-01 - Paul Butler - PB Planning - Duchy Homes – Hearing Statement MM12

ST3030 - Robert Harding - Lichfields - CEG Group
ST3030-01 - Robert Harding - Lichfields - CEG Group – Hearing Statement MM12
ST3030-02 - Robert Harding - Lichfields - CEG Group – Hearing Statement MM15
ST3030-03 - Updated Hearing Statement MM15

Page 8

ST3031 - Paul Butler - PB Planning - Yorkshire Land Limited
ST3031-01 - PB Planning - YLL Hearing Statement MM10
ST3031-02 - PB Planning - YLL Hearing Statement MM12
ST3031-03 - PB Planning - YLL Hearing Statement MM13
ST3031-04 - PB Planning - YLL Hearing Statement MM14
ST3031-Ap1 - MM10 - YLL - Blackmoor Business Park Aerial Photograph
ST3031-Ap2 - MM10 - YLL - Tunnel Photo
ST3031-Ap3 - MM10 - YLL - Facebook Post and Photos
ST3031-Ap4 - MM10 - YLL - MoD Disposal Report
ST3031-Ap5 - MM12 Allocations Deliverability Assessment Common Ground 09-2017
ST3031-Ap6 - MM12 Allocations Deliv. Assessment 09-2017 - Min. Report
ST3031-Ap7 - MM12 Allocations Deliverability Assessment - Site Schedule - 07-2016
ST3031-Ap8 - MM13 Savills - Delivery Rates on Urban Extensions Final Report
ST3031-Ap9 - MM14 Oxspring Fields Masterplan
ST3031-Ap10 - MM14 - Oxspring Fields Tourism Hub

ST3032 - Stacey Green - Barton Willmore - Church Commissioners for England
ST3032-01 - Stacey Green - Barton Willmore - Ch Co MM12

Page 9

ST3033 - Steven Green - Yorkshire Land Limited
ST3033-01 - Yorkshire Land Limited Hearing Statement MM10
ST3033-02 - Yorkshire Land Limited Hearing Statement MM12
ST3033-03 - Yorkshire Land Limited Hearing Statement MM14

ST3034 - Will Mulvany - Spawforths - Barnsley West Consortium
ST3034-01 - Spawforths - BWC – Hearing Statement MM10
ST3034-02 - Spawforths - BWC – Hearing Statement MM12
ST3034-03 - Spawforths - BWC – Hearing Statement MM13
ST3034-04 - Spawforths - BWC – Hearing Statement MM14
ST3034-05 - Spawforths - BWC - Hearing Statement - MM15
ST3034-Ap1 - Spawforths Masterplan Rev A September 2017

ST3035 - Will Mulvany - Spawforths - Jones Homes Limited
ST3035-01 - Spawforths - Jones Homes – Haring Statement MM12

ST3036 - Will Mulvany - Spawforths - Network Space
ST3036-01 - Spawforths - Network Space – Hearing Statement MM12
ST3036-02 - Spawforths - Network Space – Hearing Statement MM13

There appears to be quite a lot of detail required, but most of them would have been posted when the site was down (see my previous FOI - Barnsley Local Plan, Timeline of Examination Events - website pages down time in September 2017).

Any problems or queries, then please come back to me!

Many thanks!

Yours faithfully,
John

John H Earnshaw, FCIH
Freelance Housing, Regeneration & Crime Reduction Consultant

Celebrating 50 years membership of the Chartered Institute of Housing and

Member of the National Housing Taskforce (APPG) Housing & Planning

Associate Member of the National CLT Network
and
Technical Advisor to the CLT Fund
http://www.cltfund.org.uk/technical-advi...

Lansdown Housing Consultancy
PO Box 3609
BARNSLEY

Linkedin - http://www.linkedin.com/profile/view?id=...

In my pursuit of the legality of Green Belt Reviews and other related issues with Alok Sharma MP, Minister of State for Housing & Planning, and I quote his words - “We are absolutely clear that the Green Belt must be protected and that there are other areas that local authorities must pursue first, such as brownfield land and taking steps to increase density on urban sites”

Information Requests, Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council

Ref: FOIA/1583

Dear John

Re: Request for Information – Freedom of Information Act 2000

Thank you for your request for information about times local plan hearing statements were uploaded to the website.

Your email request was received on 24 November 2017 and I am dealing with it under the terms of the Freedom of Information Act 2000.

Your request will be processed as soon as possible, and we will try to provide the information within 20 working days as required. The deadline date when the information should be available to you is 22 December 2017.

In some circumstances a fee may be payable and if that is the case, I will let you know the likely charges before proceeding.

If you have any queries about this email, please contact me. Please remember to quote the reference number above in any future communications.

Yours sincerely,

Tom Grierson

Customer Feedback and Improvement Officer
Customer Feedback and Improvement Team
Customer Services

Mail: Barnsley MBC, Feedback and Improvement Team, Gateway Plaza, Sackville Street, Barnsley, S70 9GG
Tel: 01226 775759
Email: [Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council request email]
Secure Email: [email address]

show quoted sections

Information Requests, Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council

1 Attachment

Good Morning,

Please find attached the response to your recent FOI request.

Regards,

Tom Grierson

Customer Feedback and Improvement Officer
Customer Feedback and Improvement Team
Customer Services

Mail: Barnsley MBC, Feedback and Improvement Team, Gateway Plaza, Sackville Street, Barnsley, S70 9GG
Tel: 01226 770770

show quoted sections

Dear Information Requests,

Thank you for your reply!

I think you had better check your records and titles of documents that are and have been on the Local Plan section and in particular the links you have posted in your reply as they are not the ones I am refering to and you are mixing them up!

Timeline of Examination Events
https://www.barnsley.gov.uk/services/pla...
Look at 22nd and 28th September 2017.

"For the avoidance of doubt, regarding the earlier request of 5th October, the
website didn’t have any ‘down time’ during September. The link provided was
broken because it had been replaced with a later version, as detailed below:

1.  https://www.barnsley.gov.uk/media/6545/i...
programme-22-09-17.pdf - September hearing timetable (broken)

2.  https://www.barnsley.gov.uk/media/6912/i...
programme-20-10-17.pdf - Replaced by October hearing timetable".

I have printed off copies on various dates and times in my posesssion and your copies do not corespond to the ones I am requesting, especially the second one!

Please explain!

Yours sincerely,

John Earnshaw

Information Requests, Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council

Good Morning,

I am unsure as to what explanation you require. The links sent in our response were with regards to your previous request on 5th October, which you referenced in your most recent request.

I would not recommend saving links to pdf documents as if the document is updated the link will change and the link you have will no longer work.

Regards,

Tom Grierson

Customer Feedback and Improvement Officer
Customer Feedback and Improvement Team
Customer Services

Mail: Barnsley MBC, Feedback and Improvement Team, Gateway Plaza, Sackville Street, Barnsley, S70 9GG
Tel: 01226 770770

show quoted sections