SUA complaints : councillors & Monitoring Officer

Janik2 made this Rhyddid Gwybodaeth request to Slough Borough Council

This request has been closed to new correspondence from the public body. Contact us if you think it ought be re-opened.

Roedd y cais yn rhannol lwyddiannus.

Greetings Slough Unitary Authority,

(1) Please explain the strange discrepancy of complaints about councillors. For example, the council's official report to its Audit & Corporate Governance Committee dated 29 September 2016 states at paragraph 5.2:-

The following table contains a summary of the complaints received from October
2015 (date from when current Monitoring Officer took post) to August 2016. A total
of 44 complaints were received, of which:

Rejected: Not Investigated- 11
Rejected: After Investigation – 13
Referred to Police for Further Investigation – 3
Upheld After Investigation - 4
Withdrawn - 2
Number Carried Forward – 11

However on this web site, What Do They Know dot Com,

Complaints against elected members

An unknown anonymous person published on behalf of the council these statements on 25 July 2016:-

* I can confirm there have been no formal investigation of Cllr complaints since June 2015.

|Year |Complaints received|Referred for |No further action|Breach| | | |investigations | | |

|15/16|0 |0 |0 |0 |
|16/17|0 |0 |0 |0 |

(2) Please reveal, in the interests of public accountability and alleged transparency (meaning no cover-ups) the names, the alleged offences and the results of the police referral mentioned above, which are:-

* Referred to Police for Further Investigation – 3

(3) What is the difference between a "formal investigation" and an "investigation" ?

(4) Since being appointed as deputy Monitoring Officer and Monitoring Officer, please itemised the status of all complaints received by solicitor Linda Walker.

(5) How many complaints have been made against solicitor Linda Walker and what are the status of those complaints (please include the grievances of elected councillors who received defamatory letters from Linda Walker) ?

(6) To whom should the public address their complaints against the current Monitoring Officer solicitor Linda Walker as normally complaints are made to the Monitoring Officer ?

Thank you.

Mr Janik

FOI, Slough Borough Council

Thank you for your email.


Providing excellent customer services is one of the council’s key


Your enquiry will now be forwarded to the relevant department to answer.


We will reply fully to all written enquiries within 10 working days
although we aim to reply to emails sooner than this.


If your enquiry is a Freedom of Information request, the council may take
up to 20 working days to respond.



If you do not receive a satisfactory response by this time you can contact
our complaints department. More details here:


'Disclaimer: You should be aware that all e-mails received and sent by
this Organisation are subject to the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and
therefore may be disclosed to a third party. (The information contained in
this message or any of its attachments may be privileged and confidential
and intended for the exclusive use of the addressee).  The views expressed
may not be official policy but the personal views of the originator.  If
you are not the addressee any disclosure, reproduction, distribution,
other dissemination or use of this communication is strictly prohibited. 
If you received this message in error please return it to the originator
and confirm that you have deleted all copies of it. All messages sent by
this organisation are checked for viruses using the latest antivirus
products.  This does not guarantee a virus has not been transmitted.  
Please therefore ensure that you take your own precautions for the
detection and eradication of viruses.'


Visible links

_Freedom of Information, Slough Borough Council

This is to acknowledge receipt of your FoI request which is receiving attention

dangos adrannau a ddyfynnir

Gadawodd Mustafa Khan anodiad ()

This is shocking. If a monitoring officer cannot get facts right about one of the main function of their job, what does that say about the council. A solicitor really should know better and check the information they are sending out. Who manages this person?

Gadawodd Janik2 anodiad ()

To the best of my current knowledge, I verily believe the for-a-very-long-time temporary Monitoring Officer is officially "managed" by the temporary Chief Executive Mr Roger Parkin. If I am mistaken, please will someone correct me.

Whether the temporary Chief Executive possesses the necessary intellect, skills and time to effectively manage non-junior council staff is debatable.

At present the council's acclaimed Head of Legal remains suspended for reasons unknown.

Slough Council is a confused jumble.

Gadawodd Mustafa Khan anodiad ()

An interim monitoring officer, Linda Walker being managed by an interim chief executive, Roger Parkin. Two interim statutory officers out of 3 a council must have, is clear sign of poorly managed local council. A Council Leader manages the Chief Executive. I have seen the headlines from last year, it looks like there will be another chief executive payoff because of a poor line management. More public money wasted.

Gadawodd Slough Witch anodiad ()

I believe the Section 151 officer is Stephen Fitzgerald who is also an interim...

Gadawodd Ms T Murphy anodiad ()


3 out of 3 statutory officers are temps. No wonder the council is in a mess.

On Saturday 6 May 2017 at the annual, and secret, meeting of Labour councillors, there were two contenders for the Leader of the Labour Group - Cllr Sohail Munawar and Cllr James "Lets bulldozer everything down, especially if its been up longer than 5 years" Swindlehurst. Cllr Munawar received 21 of the 33 Labour councillor votes and thus won.

However Cllr Munawar is incapable of ensuring the proper and efficient organisation of the council. Rumours claim the chief exec's job advertisement will not be issued until JUNE despite the vacancy allegedly occurring, according to the useful Slough Times, in November last year.

There is obviously a willing tolerance, by councillors from all parties (Conservatives, UKIP and Labour), to ignored the disorganised criss hampering the council's operations. Last week someone said Nick Hannon has left for Milton Keynes. The council is haemorrhaging irreplaceable talent to the joint detriment of council and public.

Gadawodd Slough Swan anodiad ()

This whole matter is too strange to be true. All the important posts are held by interims?

Surely someone should be complaining to central government, or at least the officials at DCLG about Slough malfunctioning.

Who actually is to blame for the status quo and why haven't the newspapers - Express and Observer - picked-up on this? Are they still letting the council's advertising revenue replace their journalistic duties and scruples?

Gadawodd Mustafa Khan anodiad ()

It seems then that Labour Councillors are to blame for this mess as they are responsible and accountable. They have no experience and some find it difficult to speak clearly or make sense when they do. See utube of Leader speak on the new football ground. It is exbarrassing to have a leader who cannot speak with any confidence or make sense when he does.

The section 151 officer is now permanent. A Neil Wilcox, but another officer with no track record for working in a challenging authority. I could find no information on him being a chief financial officer before Slough. Like the interim Monitoring Officer, who also has no history of being an Monitoring Officer anywhere except Slough.

Gadawodd Slough Swan anodiad ()

Neil Wilcox seems a likeable and friendly person.His heart appears to be in the right place for a better Slough but will he be supported ?

Dear Mrs Ward and various assistants,

I am willing to accept a partial reply as an interim response. It would be most helpful if you will describe the apparent difficulties causing the council to disobey the 2000 c.36 Act.

If you, or unknown others lurking behind the scenery, believe any of my questions are unreasonable kindly tell me. If you, or others, verily believe the requested information should be kept secret then please tell me. If you, or others, simply do not know how to answer those questions, please tell me.

I have always been a very reasonable person despite the massive injustices done to me by some of Slough Unitary Authority staff and councillors. Just because I am against council incompetence and council corruption there is no good reason to give me a bad service or even no service.

Yours sincerely,

Mr Janik.

Gadawodd Slough Witch anodiad ()

Has SUA acknowledged that their response is late? Or, have they simply ignored their obligation to respond within the statutory time limit?

Gadawodd Slough Witch anodiad ()

the original requester has been more than adequately patient and the authority has not had the good manners to excuse their tardiness.

The request is now a week overdue. Time to go to the ICO, I suggest:

Gadawodd Mustafa Khan anodiad ()

So the council Monitoring Officer is not following the law! She is a solicitor. There are rules that govern conduct of solicitors some one should complain to the law society.

Ward Jane, Slough Borough Council

Dear Mr Janik


I am still awaiting the response to this one.

I will of course continue to chase.


Regards, SBC FOI Officer



dangos adrannau a ddyfynnir

Gadawodd Mustafa Khan anodiad ()

The requester should complain to the auditor, as there is a governance problem.

Gadawodd Robert Abdesselam anodiad ()

You jest Mr Khan. The entire authority is riddled with sleazy, incompetence and parasites.

_Freedom of Information, Slough Borough Council

Dear Mr Janik


Please see below.

Please accept my apologies for the lateness of this response.


Regards, SBC FOI Officer




dangos adrannau a ddyfynnir

Gadawodd Mustafa Khan anodiad ()

Linda Walker paid over £100k for a few days a week for last year, and she cannot get a report right or is she trying to mislead the public to keep her well paid consultancy job?

Gadawodd Slough Witch anodiad ()

Probably both...

Gadawodd Mustafa Khan anodiad ()

I am told that the best place to report a council that does not comply with the law is to the department of communities and local government. The more complaints the more likely the council will be investigated.

Gadawodd Slough Witch anodiad ()

It is shocking that a serious discrepancy of this sort, involving a former monitoring officer is of so little concern to the authority that they are unable (and it appears unwilling) to account for it.

Gadawodd Slough Frog anodiad ()

On Slough Times Grapevine Gossip, 2 of the 3 missing councillors complaints were one sending porn from his council Iphone and a councillor on Housing Benefits trying to buy her council home.

Gadawodd Slough Witch anodiad ()

I think we will have to take care in future.

I wouldn't want my familiars to see such things. I am sure you feel the same way about your tadpoles, Frog. The innocence of childhood could be shattered.