Follow this request
There is 1 person following this request
Act on what you've learnt
Similar requests
Species-level taxonomy
To Natural England by Susan Davis 25 September 2008
Specialist species groups
To Joint Nature Conservation Committee by Susan Davis 2 October 2008
NHM Species Dictionary
To The Natural History Museum by Susan Davis 11 November 2008
NHM Species dictionary
To The Natural History Museum by Susan Davis 25 September 2008
Species-level taxonomy
To Countryside Council for Wales / Cyngor Cefn Gwlad Cymru by Susan Davis 25 September 2008
Species-level taxonomy
To Scottish Natural Heritage by Susan Davis 27 September 2008
NVC database
To Joint Nature Conservation Committee by Susan Davis 6 April 2009
Quinquennial reviews of the Wildlife and Countryside Act
To Joint Nature Conservation Committee by Susan Davis 13 July 2010
delegating public responsibilities
To Joint Nature Conservation Committee by ben addison 24 October 2008
Species-level taxonomy
Susan Davis made this Freedom of Information request to Joint Nature Conservation Committee
The request was partially successful.
From: Susan Davis
16 September 2008
Dear Sir or Madam,
I would like to learn about JNCC's approach to species-level
taxonomy.
Please could you tell me, for each taxonomic group which it works
with, what approach JNCC uses to ensure that the species-level
taxonomy it uses for that group is up-to-date and accurate? How,
for example, do you ensure that appropriate, consistent and current
species concepts or criteria are applied within and between groups,
and how do you ensure that individual changes proposed in the
scientific literature are evaluated, and if appropriate, adopted?
What processes and information sources are used to support these
approaches, what advisory bodies does JNCC use for this, and are
changes adopted on a periodic or a rolling basis?
Thank you
From: Sue McQueen
Joint Nature Conservation Committee
19 September 2008
Dear Ms Davies,
Thank you for your enquiry. We will provide you with a response by 15th October, 2008.
Regards
Sue McQueen
show quoted sections
From: Sue McQueen
Joint Nature Conservation Committee
22 September 2008
Dear Ms Davis,
In respone to your enquiry about JNCC's aproach to species-level taxonomy, we use the NBN dictionary for all taxanomic groups. This is maintained by the Natural History Museum and can be accessed at http://nbn.nhm.ac.uk/nhm/. Unfortunately we do not hold the information about how these lists are maintained However, there is a link at the bottom of the web page to the dictionary manager, who may be able to assist you further.
Yours Sincerely
Sue McQueen.
show quoted sections
From: Susan Davis
22 September 2008
Dear Sue,
Thank you for your reply. I've taken a look at the NBN species
dictionary, and I have two further questions.
The dictionary does not just contain a single taxonomic treatment
for every taxon, but consists of a number of overlapping lists, and
these different lists use different taxonomic treatments in many
cases. In some cases (e.g. Herring Gull) the dictionary manager has
been able to match entries in one list with those in another,
minimising the number of duplicate entries across all lists, but in
other cases (e.g. European Nightjar) this has not been done.
My two additional questions are:
i) where there is more than one group of matches relating to the
same taxon, what rules does JNCC apply to decide which treatment to
follow?
ii) within a matched group, no "master" taxonomic treatment for
each matched group is listed. What rules does JNCC apply to decide
which taxonomic treatment to follow?
Yours sincerely,
Susan Davis
From: Sue McQueen
Joint Nature Conservation Committee
23 September 2008
Dear Ms Davis,
In answer to your additional questions please see the following information.
Within the dictionary there are lists that are flagged as preferred lists i.e. the field "TAXON_LIST_VERSION.RECOMMENDED_LIST" is set to true. Where at all possible the matches should be made to entries on these lists that, currently, contain very little if any overlap. Where the name is not on one of these we would attempt to match to the Marine Conservation Society's marine species list and where that fails use the Recorder 3 list. All of these lists are actually contained within the species dictionary
In addition to this there is a name matching facility (held within the NAMESERVER table in the dictionary). This is not complete but in essence attempts to match a name to a current preferred name (ie. one that exists on one of the preferred lists) and includes information on the state of the match etc. So the name "Herring Gull" might not appear directly on a preferred list but its scientific name would and the Nameserver table would match the common name to its scientific name.
I hope this information is useful. Further information (including the meaning of the codes etc) can be obtained form the Natural History Museum.
Yours Sincerely
Sue McQueen
show quoted sections
From: Susan Davis
23 September 2008
Dear Sue,
Thanks for this clarification. Could you provide me with a list of
the lists which have Preferred List status, or let me know how I
can find this information out?
Yours sincerely,
Susan
From: Sue McQueen
Joint Nature Conservation Committee
25 September 2008
Dear Susan,
As it is the Natural History Museum who is responsible for the Species Dictionary and the website please contact the Dictionary Manager there for further information. The link to the Dictionary Manager is on this web page http://nbn.nhm.ac.uk/nhm/.
Kind regards
Sue
show quoted sections
From: Susan Davis
10 October 2008
Dear Sue,
Many thanks for your help with this request. I have been in touch
with NHM and they have been able to provide me with the full list
of Preferred lists.
Yours sincerely,
Susan Davis
From: Sue McQueen
Joint Nature Conservation Committee
13 October 2008
Thanks for the feedback.
Sue
show quoted sections
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
- Download a zip file of all correspondence
Make and explore Freedom of Information requests






Susan Davis left an annotation ( 2 October 2008)
http://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/nh...
Link to this