Hello! (Sign in or sign up)

Track this request

Act on what you've learnt

Similar requests

Complaints and Investigations of DC Magnus Scott Apologies Mr Henderson on looking back at our records, when I became aware that this request was still outstanding on whatdotheyknow.com, I found t... Rejected.
Response by Devon and Cornwall Constabulary to Nick Henderson on 22 June 2009.
Devon & Cornwall Constabulary Homophobia (continued IV) Dear Mr Lidbury, I write to in connection with your request for information dated May 29, 2009, which was received by Devon and Cornwall Constabul... Rejected.
Acknowledgement by Devon and Cornwall Constabulary to Malcolm Lidbury on 3 June 2009.
Speeding offences on A379 Dear Mr Galer, FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST NO 752/2009-2685 I write in connection with your email dated September 29, 2009, which was rec... Successful.
All information sent by Devon and Cornwall Constabulary to V Galer on 15 October 2009.

More similar requests

Event history details

Are you the owner of any commercial copyright on this page?

Homophobic hate crimes reported to police

A Freedom of Information request to Devon and Cornwall Constabulary by Nick Henderson

The request was rejected by Devon and Cornwall Constabulary.

Nick Henderson

24 October 2008

Dear Sir or Madam,

Could you please inform me of

[1a] the total number of homophobic hate crimes reported to you in
the last year

[b] the last three years

[2a] the total number of those hate crimes that were reported to
the Crown Prosecution Service in the last year

[b] the last three years.

Thank you

Yours faithfully,

Nick Henderson

Link to this | Send follow up

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

27 October 2008

Dear Mr Henderson

I write in connection with your request for information which was received
by this office on October 27, 2008. I understand you are requesting the
following information:

[1a] the total number of homophobic hate crimes reported to you in
the last year
[b] the last three years
[2a] the total number of those hate crimes that were reported to
the Crown Prosecution Service in the last year
[b] the last three years.

Your request will be considered in accordance with the Freedom of
Information Act 2000. Normally you should expect to be sent a response
within the statutory limit of 20 working days, subject to the provisions
of the Act. Unfortunately staffing in the FOI Unit is currently reduced
by two thirds and it may not be possible to meet the statutory limit.
Please be assured that all efforts will be made to meet the statutory
limit but if this is not possible late requests will be treated in
chronological order. The Information Commissioner is aware of the current
situation. If we are unable to respond to your request in time I
apologise for any inconvenience that this may cause.

Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please
contact me quoting my reference number as above.

Yours sincerely

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. http://www.devon-cornwall.police.uk/

Link to this | Reply to this message

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

27 October 2008

Dear Mr Henderson,

I write in connection with your request for information, which was
received on October 27, 2008 requesting the following information:

[1a] the total number of homophobic hate crimes reported to
you in
the last year
[b] the last three years
[2a] the total number of those hate crimes that were reported to
the Crown Prosecution Service in the last year
[b] the last three years.

Unfortunately I am unable to progress with your request at this time. To
enable us to meet your request please could you provide this office with
further information, such as do you request the information to be
presented in financial year or Calendar year?

After receiving your reply, your request will then be considered and you
will receive the information requested within the statutory 20 working
days as defined under the Act, subject to the provisions of that Act.

However, if the requested information has not been received by January 19,
2009 I will assume you will no longer wish to proceed with this request
and it will be treated as withdrawn.

Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please
contact me quoting my reference number as above.

Yours sincerely,

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. http://www.devon-cornwall.police.uk/

Link to this | Reply to this message

Nick Henderson

18 February 2009

Dear Sir or Madam,

I responded to this email stating it was calendar year, but I
believe there may have been a problem with the system.

I would appreciate if you were able to reopen this request and sned
me the information

Thank you

Yours sincerely,

Nick Henderson

Link to this | Send follow up

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

26 February 2009

Dear Mr Henderson

Apologies for the lateness of this email.

Unfortunately your email was not received within the 60 days after we sent the clarification email to yourself. We subsequently closed this request towards the end of January 2009.

Therefore, your request will have to submitted again as a new request. Please let me know if you would like this request to be resubmitted with the clarification of calendar year as stated below.

Kind Regards

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

Link to this | Reply to this message

Nick Henderson

8 March 2009

Dear Sir or Madam,

Please re-submit this request with the relevant clarification
included.

Yours sincerely,

Nick Henderson

Link to this | Send follow up

Malcolm Lidbury left an annotation (8 March 2009)

This may help explain why the Cornwall police are dragging their heals responding to the initial enquiry.

In 2004, the LGBT Intercom Trust asked Lidbury to assist with a forum on Cornwall LGBT community opinion of the Criminal Justice Service as part of research for the Lord Justice Kay award 2005.The original location for the lgbt meeting cancelled in part due to the conduct and actions of Helston police officer DC woods (thankfully retired) against Mr Lidbury.

Valuable insight into Cornwall police thinking & attitudes against gay persons between 2004-07.

DC Magnus Scott has much to answer for his instigation of abuses against gay people in Cornwall carried out by the Cornwall police

# When a gay employer enabled 16/17yr old student gay/bi employees to attend a GU Clinic in work time to receive professional sexual health advice & inoculations against Hepatitis…Cornwall police considered this to be an offence of ‘SEXUAL GROOMING”

# When a gay employer allowed 16/17yr old gay/bi student employees to watch a gay themed film on a rainy day, NB: The film was the 15 Certificate comedy, “The Birdcage”, starring Gene Hackman & Robin Williams....Cornwall police considered this to be “SEXUAL GROOMING”.

# When a 16yr old ‘out’ gay youth (S. Read) choose a ‘Secret Santa’ gift of a pair of Tesco Christmas underpants & a small rubber novelty willy key ring for his 17yr old bisexual closet boyfriend (D. Tressider). ...Cornwall Police considered this to be “SEXUAL GROOMING”.

# When a woman spread rumours (T. Tressider) that a gay man had HIV/AIDS (he did not and had to prove it with a letter from the GU Clinic) & screamed homophobic abuse at him in the streets in front of a witness. Her son later confided that his mother conspired with another over a false allegation against a gay man.

Cornwall police (Inspector Bolt, previously of Helston) stated in 'writing' this was NOT (HOMOPHOBIC) harassment.

This is merely the tip of the iceberg of reported but un-investigated homophobic police incidents against lgbt persons in Cornwall, UK.

A protracted four-year period of conflict followed between Lidbury and the Cornwall police who raided his home in Nov 2004, arresting him & seizing his computer.

The four year vendetta & abuses by Cornwall police is still continuing unabated against Mr Lidbury, No criminal charges resulted against Lidbury for false allegations made and police Criminal Forensics admitted both in an Independent Police Complaints Commission report & in Civil Crown Court in Sept 2006 there were NO ‘alleged’ illegal images on the computer.

However, Lidbury's businesses were entirely destroyed by the police actions. This has never been addressed.

Lidbury: a listed gay artist with a Middlesex University Archive of gay artists, along with Hockney, Mapplethorpe, Gilbert, & George.

In Nov 97, Lidbury had jointly exhibited at the Penzance Art Club his male bronze figures with Leigh Heppell a sculptor of erotic female forms. Lidbury has Artwork in the Barcelona Spanish Museum of Erotic Art and Homosexual Art Foundation in New York, USA.In 2004, Cornwall police attempted unsuccessfully to prosecute Lidbury for his perfectly legal homocentric Art.

In Civil Court, Judge Rucker homophobically condemned and referred to Lidbury’s 20 year contribution to gay equality & HIV/AIDS care treatment & awareness campaigning as ‘Evangelical Proselytising’.

Regarding assistance Lidbury & his mother had given to 16/17yr old gay/bi youth, the Judge referred to the equal age of consent becoming effective with the Sexual Offences Act 2003 (effective 1st May 2004), this was of course wrong as the age of equal consent of homosexuals with heterosexuals became effective 1st Jan 2001.

THE JUDGE WAS WRONG & HOMOPHOBIC in the opinion of ALL the many gay persons in the public gallery!Assistance given to a homeless Cornish gay youth (and by Lidbury's 75yr old pensioner mother, who became the youths landlady ) was described by the Judge as “Grossly Irresponsible”, even in the total absence & refusal of assistance to him as a gay youth by the Cornish Authorities. Cornwall police withheld a consider number of statements given by members of the public regarding the abuse by police.

It was entirely ignored by the court that Cornwall police, Cornwall Social Services, Cornwall youth services & Cornwall education dept. had ALL been fully aware that the 15yr old youth had been living homeless & rough on the streets of Helston for 2 months as a 15yr old child.

The authorities of Cornwall did absolutely NOTHING to help the homeless gay youth! This sort of homophobic abuse is the accepted norm by the Cornish authorities and abusive Cornwall police officers like those named & identified throughout this blog.

Cornwall Social Services failed entirely to meet a single one of their own objectives they set themselves at his case conference, adding to the abuse he had already suffered in the family home & homophobic environment of Helston school & Jim Walters, a Cornwall Social Worker attempted to blackmail the gay youth. (This was recorded by Mr JC Smith)

In the absence of ANY authority assistance, Mr Lidbury had been asked by some members of the public & serving members of the Navy to assist the gay youth.None of the gay supporters in the public gallery that day, left court without the knowledge that Institutional Homophobia within both the Cornwall police & the judicial system in Cornwall was, still and remains a sinister & grave problem....today in 2008/09

Members of the Lidbury household have continued to be relentlessly targeted & intimidated by Cornwall police.
Despite reporting to Cornwall police:-

. attempted blackmail
. theft from the property
. car damage
. threats of physical assault & violence

Cornwall police DO NOTHING due to involvement of their own police officers in instigating these offences against members of the Lidbury household

In 2006, Lidbury’s 74yr old pensioner mother was verbally abused by Cornwall police (abuser PC Alexander of Helston) when Mrs Lidbury went to give witness assistance to a gay youth being persecuted by police.

The youth was already a witness against police for other formal complaints of police homophobic conduct made to the IPCC.The youth was detained by police in a chapel coffee morning, he was subjected to a partial strip search, sworn at, and then forcibly taken by police to a retail outlet.

The shop staff positively identified the youth WAS NOT the person who had stolen an item. Police then failed to give a stop and search form & failed to apologise to the youth or his pensioner landlady, Mrs Lidbury. The reason police gave for targeting the gay youth was he had ‘Blue Hair’.

This is the Cornwall authority & Cornwall police abused gay youth, Peter Midwood's own video which he co-created & produced on his own video channel on youtube.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sr7eGX-Ru... remains the opinion of those involved, police deliberately targeted the gay youth as he was a witness in formal IPCC complaint procedures against other Cornwall police officers, namely PC Tar & another abusive officer.

The person who was actually responsible for the theft later detained & prosecuted by police, however there has never been an apology from Cornwall police for the abusive intimidation & treatment by PC Alexander & the other police officer, neither to the innocent gay youth or his pensioner landlady, but that’s the HOMOPHOBIC Cornwall police for you.

In May 2006, Lidbury along with another gay/bi male were violently assaulted in Helston Cornwall. The other gay/bi male was bottled over the head, and then violently kicked in the head, face chest & stomach by the assailants.

Mr Lidbury shielded the prone victim with his body, preventing attempts by the assailants to stamp on the victims head. The assault witnessed by numerous persons, many of whom were also gay. However when the victim reported to the police it was a ‘homophobic assault’, police told the victim Mr P Lealand to: quote “Shut up, be quiet, you don’t want to say that”.

This entirely contrary to the 'True Vision' police policy on dealing with a homophobic incident & CPS (Crown Prosecution Service) policy on homophobic incidents.The police then allowed the assailants to leave the scene (the police helped them into a taxi) despite Mr Lidbury having positively identified the assailants to police.

Mr Lidbury took the injured male to hospital for stitches & x-ray. Directly due to the hostile & prejudicial attitude of the police attending the scene, none of the other gay persons witness to the incident felt safe to come forward to Cornwall police.

Mr Lidbury attended voluntarily the following day to the local Helston police station where he was threatened by police if he (Lidbury) pursued making a complaint regarding the incident, they would prosecute the other gay victim.

The gay youth previously abused & targeted by police was just one of the several witnesses who did not feel safe to come forward as a witness due to personal experiences of homophobic police in Cornwall.

Cornwall police have ALAWAYS refused to identify the police officers responsible for this abuse.The police intimidation regarding an alleged (false) rape allegation involving Mr Lealand was most successful in intimidating the victim Mr Lealand into not proceeding against the Helston police officers concerned.

August 2006, Lidbury was again violently assaulted. The entire assault captured on CCTV, however, once again none of the four other gay witnesses present felt confident in involving Cornwall’s well-known & renowned homophobic police force.Lidbury’s complaint of police misconduct lead to two separate Independent Police Complaints Commission 'partial' investigations 2004/2006 resulting in numerous recommendations being made to Devon & Cornwall Constabulary of needed improvement of public service.

These are some of the FACTS the IPCC DID establish regarding complaint made by a gay person in Cornwall, but NOTHING has been done about these incidents or the catalogue of other Cornwall police abuses highlighted:

1. A Cornwall police officer lied about a (non-existent) signature in a pocket book. Abuser in the company of PC Tar (Camborne)
2. Police failed to provide (withheld) legal court documentation. abuse by PC Tar of Camborne
3. Police failed to return a computer after it had been cleared by police forensics (police kept it for weeks in a lock up garage or similar) abuse by DC Anning
4. Police did make un-logged (not recorded by police) visits to the family home (these were most intimidating to his elderly mother) abuse by PC Tar & another, also DC Crowe & DS Beckerlegge
5. kept a gay person on a computer as a suspect AFTER the case had been NFA'd (no further action) abuse by DC Anning
6. failed to provide food for over 7 hours whilst a suspect was in custody. Abuse by Camborne custody officers
7. failed to inform a gay suspect weeks after a case had been finalised that there was no further actionAbuse by DC Anning again
8. there was no means to follow received mail into Exeter Middlemore police HQ within the internal system of the police headquarters, therefore no quality control on delivery of service However the IPCC despite the ESTABLISHED above police abuses admit in their report they did not (bother) to interview fourteen witnesses regarding a catalogue of other complaints made!

Many aspects & further reported complaints of Cornwall police conduct against gay persons still remain entirely un-investigated. (see:- 25% of official complaints against Devon & Cornwall police officially go un-investigated/completed)

These are further complaints regarding Cornwall police conduct the IPCC choose NOT to investigate and still remain buried to the utter frustration and angst of the gay victims of Cornwall police continuing homophobic abuses:-

1. Failure of ‘Duty of Care’ to a homeless 15yr old teenage gay youth (UNIVESTIGATED) abuse by PC Treloar & PC Fuller of Helston
2. Attempted blackmail of a teenage gay youth (UNINVESTIGATED) abuse by DC Scott of Camborne
3. Abuse of a gay teenager in a strip search & botched ‘Stop & Search’ (UNIVESTIGATED) abuse by PC Alexander & another police officer
4. Seizing of a computer leading to destruction of a gay businesses (UNIVESTIGATED) abuse DC Anning & senior officers
5. Failure to follow ‘TRUE VISION’ & CPS definition of ‘Homophobic Incident’ following serious physical assault of two gay/bi persons (UNIVESTIGATED) abuse by Three Helston Police Officers
6. Refusal to take statements from Gay/Bi witnesses (UNIVESTIGATED) abuse by Sgt. Rowe of Helston
7. Perjury by a police officer in Crown Court (UNINVESTIGATED) abuse by DC Scott of Camborne
8. Further un-logged visits by police officers to further intimidate complaintents against the police (UNIVESTIGATED) abuse by DC Crowe & DS Beckerlegge
9. Refusal of a police Sgt. to take a witness statement from an adult gay eyewitness (a founding member of Cornwall's lesbian women's publication OUTBACK was witness to this police refusal) (UNINVESTIGATED) abuse by Sgt Rowe of Helston
10. Only an 'out' gay person was arrested out of a group of people equally taking part in lawful activity (No charges were made against the gay person. ( UNINVESTIGATED) abuse by DC Parker who also ignored text msgs from the false accuser ADMITTING it was a false allegation against the gay man & failed to return lawful belongings seized by police

But that's merely the tip of the corrupt, dishonest & homophobic attitudes & practises common place within the Cornwall police force

The appointment of three new diversity police officers to the Cornwall police force was an immediate effect of the partially investigated catalogue of complaints made against the Cornwall police by Lidbury (and others also whose complaints have NEVER been investigated).

In 2007, aspects of Lidbury’s gay life were researched as contribution to a London Drill Hall Theatre stage play,‘A gay man’s guide’.

In August 2007, Cornwall Police once again arrested Lidbury, just days PRIOR to the Cornwall PRIDE Beach Day. Lidbury was ‘Chair' of the 2007 Cornwall Gay LGBT PRIDE Beach day and the LGBT gathering was put in serious jeopardy of cancellation, contrary to the false & misleading information put out by a Cornwall police diversity officer in the media.

The 2007 Cornwall Gay PRIDE Beach Day steering group, comprising of gay men, gay women & gay youth disbanded after the 2007 PRIDE event out of fear of further police reprisals.

After months on bail, NO criminal charges, NO criminal prosecution, & NO conviction resulted towards Lidbury.

However, during the prolonged period of bail Lidbury attempted suicide due directly to Cornwall police misconduct & prolonged abuses.

He was subjected to repeated vehicle stops & un-logged visits felt to be intended to harass & continue to violate his life as an 'out' gay man and those lives of other residents in his home.

Plus Police (abuse by DC Parker) choose to ignore:-

1. There were several eyewitnesses as to the falsehood of the allegation made against Lidbury
2. There was physical evidence ignored by police
3. There were TEXT messages from the false accuser ADMITTING it was a false allegation!

Only Lidbury, an 'OUT' gay male, was targeted & arrested by police, out of a group of several people all taking part equally in lawful activity.

Such is the homophobic practises of Cornwall police. It is believed the police did not prosecute the false accuser, J Prior, as it would have raised serious issues regarding Cornwall police homophobic attitudes & practises AGAINST gay persons!

In 2007;- Lidbury was subjected to an attempted extortion & blackmail attempt by M Pascoe . This was immediately reported to Cornwall police.

However, Cornwall police (Sgt. Rowe of Helston) who refused to interview a gay direct eye-witness and dropped the investigation. Despite fresh complaints reported to various authorities, these further complaints along with many other previous complaints against Cornwall police have not been investigated!

There is some evidence to suggest that Cornwall police themselves (DC Parker) may have instigated the attempted blackmail against Mr Lidbury.

Sgt. Rowe by his own admission in front of a witness later targeted Mr Lidbury, because Rowe recognised Lidbury as a gay man who had made complaint.

Such is the abuse culture still protected within the Cornwall police force.Lidbury self-published three autobiographical book memoirs in 2007.

Mr Hopkins Legacy: - His own childhood.
NO Carrots in My Pasty: - HIV/AIDS in Cornwall.
A NO GAY ZONE: - Cornwall Police and other Homophobia?

These and several other books & Art prints by Lidbury are available from HERE

In Dec 2007:- Lidbury was voted 3rd in 'Queerwest' 'Person of Gay Influence in the Southwest'. An online lgbt news publication run by editor Craig Denney.

In June 2008:- Lidbury was contacted by the National Audit Office to give witness evidence for an investigation regarding the effectiveness of the Independent Police Complaints Commission.

Lidbury believes that gay people should consider very carefully before making a formal complaint against the police to the IPCC."In our experience an already victimised gay person can find themselves further abused & violated by the ineffectiveness and bias of the IPCC towards & in favour of the police and further intimidated and victimised by the police. That is our experience".said Lidbury

In June 2008:- Lidbury submitted evidence to a Human Rights Enquiry into institutional breaches of Human Rights.

This evidence included his personal blog http://www.pinkpasty.blogspot.com/ which raises awareness of the continuing widespread problem & numerous instances of continuing institutional homophobic attitudes & practises against gay persons in Cornwall, UK.

Devon & Cornwall Constabulary then threatened in writing prosecution, unless Lidbury removed the blog, destroying the evidence he submitted to the HRE.

This was the 2nd time Cornwall police had tried intimidation to cover up their abuses by threatening legal action against him for making public, his and other Cornwall gay persons experiences of homophobia carried out by the Cornwall police force.

In 2008:- it was made clear that Mr Lidbury & other gay persons who had made complaint of police homophobic conduct & practises were NOT welcome at a Cornwall 'pride' event, in which Cornwall police were taking a very visible involvement.

2008: There were four known gay male suicides in Cornwall this year. Cornwall police even tried to prosecute the corpse of one gay male suicide victim...twenty days after he the victim had taken his own life after being arrested by Cornwall police.

Year leading up to March 2008:- A request under the Freedom of Information Act revealed that there were over 1,200+ official complaints made AGAINST Devon & Cornwall Constabulary in that year.

The 3rd highest of the 42 police forces in the UK.Disgustingly, almost 25% of theses OFFICIAL complaints not investigated, or were buried or never finalised by the Devon & Cornwall police.

Many of these complaints from LGBT persons. Further indication of the depth & level of continuing corruption & homophobic attitudes within Devon & Cornwall Constabulary under the command of Chief Constable Steven Otter.

January 2009:- Over 1 MILLION views had been made of Malcolm Lidbury's videos on Youtube raising awareness of the continuing problem of harboured & protected homophobic attitudes & practises still prevalent within the Cornwall authorities: in particular the HOMOPHOBIC Cornwall police force.

Jan 2009:- Lidbury received a letter of thanks from Dame Nuala O'Loan DBE, chair of the British Equality & Human Rights Commission, for Lidbury's written & verbal evidence to the UK governments enquiry into Human Rights in 2008.

Most of Lidbury's evidence & hours of interview with the Criminal Research Dept. Kings College consisted of lists of abusive conduct, practises & attitudes from within the authorities of Cornwall, UK against gay people.

In particular, homophobic abuses & abusive attitudes & practises carried out from within Cornwall Police & Cornwall County Council.

Malcolm Lidbury:-"Forget hoodie wearing youth, the single most likely person to intimidate, traumatise, violate, abuse and adversely affect the life of a gay person in Cornwall...is still likely to be a Cornwall police officer".

Those who commit HOMOPHOBIC HATE CRIMES....one need look no further than police stations in Cornwall.

Link to this

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

9 March 2009

Dear Mr Henderson

I write in connection with your request for information which was received
by this office on March 9, 2009. I understand you are requesting the
following information:

[1a] the total number of homophobic hate crimes reported to you in
the last calendar year

[b] the last three calendar years

[2a] the total number of those hate crimes that were reported to
the Crown Prosecution Service in the last calendar year

[b] the last three calendar years.

Your request will be considered in accordance with the Freedom of
Information Act 2000. You should expect to be sent a response within the
statutory limit of 20 working days, subject to the provisions of the Act.

Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please
contact me quoting my reference number as above.

Yours sincerely

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. http://www.devon-cornwall.police.uk/

Link to this | Reply to this message

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

9 March 2009

Dear Mr Henderson

I write in connection with your request for information which was received
by this office on March 9, 2009. I understand you are requesting the
following information:

[1] all documents relating to any complaint made against DC Magnus
Scott

[2] all documents relating to any internal investigation of DC
Magnus Scott by Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

Your request will be considered in accordance with the Freedom of
Information Act 2000. You should expect to be sent a response within the
statutory limit of 20 working days, subject to the provisions of the Act.

Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please
contact me quoting my reference number as above.

Yours sincerely

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. http://www.devon-cornwall.police.uk/

Link to this | Reply to this message

Malcolm Lidbury left an annotation (21 March 2009)

There are many questions to be asked about even more formal (but ignored & un-investigated) complaints made about:-

PC Treloar & PC Fuller (Helston Police station) failure of 'Duty of Care') regarding their KNOWLEDGE, but failure to act on a homeless gay 15yr old youth living for months on the streets of Helston Cornwall in 2005.
This known police information was dishonestly suppressed & withheld by police from a later enquiry.

PC Alexander & (unknown) police colleague who conducted a partial strip search, intimidation, swore at & threatened the same gay youth (who was a witness against police in another IPCC enquiry of police misconduct).

The youth witness to PC Tar & coleague who with held legal & lawful court documentation from a gay victim of police homophobia & prejudice. The IPCC did establish that the court paperwork was witheld/undelivered & that one of the police officers LIED about a non-existent signature in a police pocket book.

Three police officers on duty on the night of Helston Flora Day in 2006, who threatened two gay/bi victims of a serious physical assault (one victim requiring x-rays & hospital treatment). The intimidation tactics used by police against the witnesses & victims little short of disgusting (witnesses & victims also witnesses AGAINST police in another IPCC enquiry)

DC Magnus Scott & social worker Jim Walters who attempted to blackmail a homeless gay youth & withold statutary services from him. The same Police officer later commited purgury in Crown Court by lying about who had recorded the attempt at blackmail carried out by police & social services. The event was recorded by the a tenant in the property and not as maliciously indicated by DC Scott. I will testify this police officer is responsible for a catalogue of abusive practises towards gay victims of police abuses in Cornwall.

The dishonest supression & covering up of dozens of public witness statements, and subsequent police intimidation of & misinformation to some of these witnesses.

Despite complaints repeatedly made to Devon & Cornwall police Headquarters via their website, including in emails addressed directly to Cheif Constable Steven Otter. These complaints from gay people in Cornwall have been completely & repeatedly ignored, & dishonestly & corruptly suppressed, including by the IPCC who admit they DECLINED to interview fourteen witnesses & ignored physical evidence. Indicative of the continuing problem of protectionisim within Devon & Cornwall constabulary & IPCC towards those homophobic police officers who routinely carry out homophobic attitudes & practises towards gay persons.

The refusal by Sgt Rowe of Helston police station to interview a direct adult eye witness to a reported attempted extortion of a gay victim & then the same police officer targeteing the gay gay male victim.

DC Parker who ignored evidence of text messages, witness statements & physical evidence regarding false allogations made against a gay man.

Complaint against a Diversity officer who LIED in the media regarding the impact & affect of continued pursicution by police of a gay organiser of an LGBT event in Cornwall.

Theses are just 'SOME' examples of a list of complaints (all un-investigated) made against Devon & Cornwall police officers who have repeatedly abused, traumatised & violated gay persons lives & whose complaints are un-investigated & have not been taken into account regarding the cronological & interconnected nature of the police abuses against gay witnesses against police misconduct, criminality & failure of duty of care carried out by known and/or identifiable police officers of Devon & Cornwall Constabulary, under the command of Chief Constable Steven Otter.

Link to this

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

24 March 2009


Attachment Record 1.doc
83K Download View as HTML


Dear Mr Henderson

I write in connection with your request for information dated March 8,
2009, which was received by this office on March 9, 2009. I note you seek
access to the following information:

[1a] the total number of homophobic hate crimes reported to you in the
last calendar year
[b] the last three calendar years

[2a] the total number of those hate crimes that were reported to the Crown
Prosecution Service in the last calendar year
[b] the last three calendar years.

Following receipt of your request searches were conducted within Devon &
Cornwall Constabulary to locate information relevant to your request. I
can confirm that this constabulary holds some of the information you have
requested.

Extent of Searches to Locate Information
To locate the information relevant to you request searches were conducted
within the Performance and Analysis Department, the Criminal Justice
Department, Crime Department and the Equality & Diversity Department.

Decision
I have today decided to disclose the requested information to you in
part.

With regard to question 2, I can confirm that information falling within
the description specified in your request is held by Devon and Cornwall
Constabulary. However, the cost of providing you with the information is
above the amount to which we are legally required to respond i.e. the cost
of locating and retrieving the information exceeds the `appropriate limit'
of 18 hours as set in the Freedom of Information and Data Protection
(Appropriate Limit and Fees) Regulations 2004.

In accordance with section 12(1) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000
this constabulary is not obliged to respond to that question within your
request and this letter acts as a Refusal Notice for that part of your
request.

The reason for this is that in order to obtain these statistics the
Criminal Justice Department would have to audit approximately 470 files
and count the number of CPS referrals, which would take in excess of 18
hours.

However, we recommend that you contact the CPS, as they may be able to
access this information within the 18-hour limit. The CPS Freedom of
Information Unit can be contacted at the following address:

The Freedom of Information Officer
CPS Headquarters
50 Ludgate Hill
London EC4M 7EX

Alternatively, you can submit a Freedom of Information request to them at
the following website link:

[1]http://www.cps.gov.uk/foi/foirequest.doc

Or by email at: [email address]

Please find attached your copy of your record numbered 1, containing the
requested information for question 1.

Copyright
The information supplied to you continues to be protected by the
Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. You are free to use it for your
own purposes, including any non-commercial research you are doing and for
the purposes of news reporting. Any other re-use, for example commercial
publication, would require the permission of the copyright holder. Most
documents supplied by the Devon and Cornwall Constabulary will be our
copyright. Applications for the copyright owner's written permission to
reproduce any part of the attached information should be addressed to The
Force Legal Department, Devon and Cornwall Constabulary, Police
Headquarters, Middlemoor, Exeter, Devon. EX2 7HQ. Information you receive
which is not subject to our copyright continues to be protected by the
copyright of the person, or organisation, from which the information
originated. You must ensure that you gain their permission before
reproducing any third party information.

Complaint Rights
If you are not satisfied with the service you have received in relation to
your request and wish to make a complaint or request a review of our
decision you should write to the Head of Information Management,
Information Management Department, Devon & Cornwall Constabulary,
Middlemoor, Exeter, EX2 7HQ, Devon.

If you are not satisfied with the outcome of your Force complaint or
review, you may apply directly to the Information Commissioner at
Commissioner's Officer, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire,
SK9 5AF, telephone 01625 545700.

Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please
contact me quoting the reference number above.

Yours sincerely

Rebecca Hudson
Assistant Freedom of Information Officer
(01392 452204 (x22204)
Information Management Department
Devon & Cornwall Constabulary

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. http://www.cps.gov.uk/foi/foirequest.doc
2. http://www.devon-cornwall.police.uk/

Link to this | Reply to this message

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

6 April 2009

Dear Mr Henderson,

Thank you for your request for information, dated March 8, 2009, which was
received by this office on March 9, 2009.

The Freedom of Information Act 2000 obliges us to respond to requests
promptly and in any case no later than 20 working days after receiving
your request. However, when a qualified exemption applies to information
and the public interest test is engaged, the Act allows time for response
to be longer than 20 working days, and a full response must be provided
within such time as is reasonable in all circumstances of the case. We
do, of course, aim to make all decisions within 20 working days, including
in cases we need to consider where the public interest lies in respect of
a request for exempt information. In this case, however, we have not yet
reached a decision on where the balance of the public interest lies.

We estimate that it will take an additional 10 working days to make a
decision on where the balance of the public interest lies. Therefore we
plan to let you have a response by April 20, 2009. If it appears that it
will take longer than this to reach a conclusion, we will keep you
informed.

The specific exemption that is being considered in relation to your
request which require the application of a public interest test is section
30(Investigations and proceedings).

Complaints
If you are not satisfied with the service you have received in relation to
your request and wish to make a complaint or request a review of our
decision you should write to the Head of Information Management,
Information Management Department, Devon & Cornwall Constabulary,
Middlemoor, Exeter, EX2 7HQ, Devon.

If you are not satisfied with the outcome of your Force complaint or
review, you may apply directly to the Information Commissioner at
Commissioner's Officer, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire,
SK9 5AF, telephone 01625 545700.
Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please
contact me quoting my reference number as above.

Yours sincerely

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. http://www.devon-cornwall.police.uk/

Link to this | Reply to this message

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

27 April 2009

Dear Mr Henderson,

My sincere apologies for the delay in sending this email. I'm afraid that
I need more time to consider the public interest in the disclosure of your
requested information. Despite the delay in sending this email I have back
dated the extension I require to the date estimated in the below email and
expect to be able to provide a response to your request on May 04, 2009.
If it appears that it will take longer than this to reach a conclusion, I
will keep you informed.

The specific exemption that is being considered in relation to your
request which require the application of a public interest test is section
30(Investigations and proceedings).

Complaints
If you are not satisfied with the service you have received in relation to
your request and wish to make a complaint or request a review of our
decision you should write to the Head of Information Management,
Information Management Department, Devon & Cornwall Constabulary,
Middlemoor, Exeter, EX2 7HQ, Devon.

If you are not satisfied with the outcome of your Force complaint or
review, you may apply directly to the Information Commissioner at
Commissioner's Officer, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire,
SK9 5AF, telephone 01625 545700.
Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please
contact me quoting my reference number as above.

Yours sincerely

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

Link to this | Reply to this message

Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

7 May 2009

Dear Mr Henderson

I write in connection with your email dated March 8, 2009, which was
received by this office on March 9, 2009 requesting the following
information:

[1] all documents relating to any complaint made against DC Magnus Scott

[2] all documents relating to any internal investigation of DC Magnus
Scott by Devon and Cornwall Constabulary

The Devon and Cornwall Constabulary can neither confirm nor deny that it
holds the information you requested. The duty in section 1(1)(a) of the
Freedom of Information Act 2000 does not apply, by virtue of sections
30(3) (investigations and proceedings); 40(5) (personal information);
41(2) (information provided in confidence). However, this should not be
taken as conclusive evidence that the information that you requested
exists or does not exist.

Therefore under section 17(4) of the Freedom of Information act this
letter acts as a Refusal Notice.

In order for you to understand this decision more fully the following
further explanation is provided.

Every Freedom of Information request must be treated on an `applicant
blind' basis, which means that we do not consider who the requester is and
why he may be asking for that information. Further, any information
disclosed means that this becomes a public document which in principle
becomes available to any member of the public. We have to be extremely
careful that harm does not arise from confirming or denying if particular
information, such as information concerning personnel/employment matters,
is held. Such confirmation in itself may lead to the identification or
harm of individuals (or in other cases may provide criminals or alleged
criminals with information that may assist them in some way). We also
have to take cognisance of the impact such a disclosure may have on future
requests for similar types of information, where by refusing the
information in one instance but not confirming or denying the information
is held in another instance, may in itself provide information that may
harm individuals or provide criminals with useful information.

Any information that Devon and Cornwall Constabulary may hold about an
individual can be requested by that individual under the Subject Access
provisions of the Data Protection Act 1998. Any disclosures of such
personal information are made in accordance with that Act. Any requests
for such information should be addressed to the Data Protection Unit at
Police Headquarters. If legal proceedings are intended, a court order may
be used to obtain this information from the Force, if it exists.

I regret that I am unable to meet your request but should you have any
further information needs in the future then please contact me.

Complaint Rights
If you are not satisfied with the service you have received in relation to
your request and wish to make a complaint or request a review of our
decision you should write to the Head of Information Management,
Information Management Department, Devon & Cornwall Constabulary,
Middlemoor, Exeter, EX2 7HQ, Devon.

If you are not satisfied with the outcome of your Force complaint or
review, you may apply directly to the Information Commissioner at
Commissioner's Officer, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire,
SK9 5AF, telephone 01625 545700.

Yours sincerely

Georgie

Georgina Kemp (56133)
Freedom of Information Assistant Officer
Tel 01392 452839 (22839)
[email address]
Freedom of Information Dept
Please consider the environment - do you really need to print this email?

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. http://www.devon-cornwall.police.uk/

Link to this | Reply to this message

Malcolm Lidbury left an annotation (7 May 2009)

...and guess what happened to those who try to expose the continuing problem of homophobic attitudes & practises within the Devon & Cornwall Constabulary

See here:-

http://pinkpasty.blogspot.com/2009/04/ho...

For dishonesty, prejudice & corruption one need look no further than a police station in Cornwall.

Link to this

Malcolm Lidbury left an annotation (26 February 2010)

A Slice of Cornwall's LGBT Homophobic History (with photos & documents) including that of the prejudice & discrimination by Devon & Cornwall Constabulary!
http://pinkpasty.blogspot.com/2010/01/sl...

Link to this

Things to do with this request

Anyone:
Devon and Cornwall Constabulary only: