Green Technology

Edwin Morris made this Freedom of Information request to Department of Energy and Climate Change

The request was successful.

From: Edwin Morris

31 December 2008

Dear Sir or Madam,
Can you please advise how wind farms can be regarded
as renewable or green technology. I very much doubt if they are
even Carbon Neutral!
They cannot generate electricity on demand which is essential since
their are no practical means of storing large amounts of
electricity.
Has any account been taken of the devastation to Britain's natural
beauty? and the destruction of wildlife and tourism?

Yours faithfully,

Edwin Morris

Link to this

From: Lajumoke Francis (REIU)
Department of Energy and Climate Change

12 January 2009


Attachment Mr Edwin Morris Wind Farms.doc
61K Download View as HTML


<<Mr Edwin Morris - Wind Farms.doc>>

Dear Mr Morris

Please find the response to your recent Freedom of information request on
wind power.

Regards
Francis Lajumoke
Renewables Deployment Team
Bay 206
BERR (Department for Business, Enterprise & Regulatory Reform)
1 Victoria Sreet, London SWIH 0ET

[email address]
Tel: 020 7215 2660
Fax: 020 7215 2609

Link to this

From: Lajumoke Francis (REIU)
Department of Energy and Climate Change

12 January 2009

Lajumoke Francis (REIU) would like to recall the message, "Mr Edwin Morris
- Wind Farms.doc ( Freedom of Information request)".

Link to this

From: Edwin Morris

12 January 2009

Dear Lajumoke Francis (REIU),

You are insulting my intelligence with this rubbish!

Yours sincerely,

Edwin Morris

Link to this

From: Lajumoke Francis (REIU)
Department of Energy and Climate Change

12 January 2009


Attachment Mr Edwin Morris Wind Farms.doc
60K Download View as HTML


<<Mr Edwin Morris - Wind Farms.doc>>

______________________________________________
Dear Mr Morris

Please find the response to your recent Freedom of information request on
wind power.

Regards
Francis Lajumoke
Renewables Deployment Team
Bay 206
BERR (Department for Business, Enterprise & Regulatory Reform)
1 Victoria Sreet, London SWIH 0ET

[email address]
Tel: 020 7215 2660
Fax: 020 7215 2609

Link to this

STtve Greatorex-Davies left an annotation (29 November 2011)

The main contribution to CO2 emissions from wind-farms arises from the back-up and balancing required from conventional power stations. This uses additional fuel - primarily gas. The National Grid in its Winter Consultation Report 2010/11 stated that 'In terms of generation availability we saw a small contribution from wind generation at the time of the demand peak, underlining the need to discount the technical availability of intermittent generation. types'. This implies 100% back-up.

Link to this

Kommando left an annotation (31 January 2012)

The DECC reply is the usual non-reply which actually confirms the complaint, for example these 4 points to which I have added my own comments

You are concerned about the ability of wind power to produce electricity on demand. While generation is a variable energy source, the effects of intermittency will increasingly be mitigated through a range of options. These include:

The geographical dispersion of wind farms across the country;

Trouble is as we have seen in the last few Winters there are long periods of blocking highs where there is no wind anywhere on the UK. FAIL

The increasing deployment of non-variable forms of renewable energy - such as biomass;

The FOI was about wind, so you are admitting that wind will need to be supplemented with biomass eg coal generators converted to wood (which we will have to import and the increase in prices is already driving furniture manufacturing overseas) FAIL

Increasing use of energy storage and

More CO2 emissions to build these plants which also increase inefficiencies FAIL

Greater demand side management.

Turning off power in cold winters FAIL

Link to this

Things to do with this request

Anyone:
Department of Energy and Climate Change only: