Conservative Councillors with free official parking permit but no paid for resident parking permit

Mr Jones made this Freedom of Information request to Westminster City Council

The request was successful.

From: Mr Jones

31 August 2009

Dear Sir or Madam,

In response to FOI number 3645, you advised that 35 Westminster
Councillors have a free official parking permit. Of these 35
Councillors, 31 belong to the Conservative party. In FOI number
4148 (being an extension to FOI 3933), you advised that 13
Conservative Councillors have purchased a resident parking permit.

I can therefore assume that 18 Conservative Councillors may have a
free official parking permit and have not purchased a resident
parking permit to park their car, outside their official working
hours.

Can you please advise on what basis these 18 Conservative
Councillors park their car in the streets of Westminster outside
their official working hours, given that in FOI 3934, you advised
that all 60 Councillors reside in Westminster, except two who
reside abroad (and are not on the list of Councillors who have a
free official parking permit, per FOI 3645)?

Yours faithfully,

Mr Jones

Link to this

Westminster City Council

1 September 2009

Confirmation of Freedom Of Information Request

Thank you for your request for information.

Your request details have now been recorded and will be passed on to the
appropriate Divisional Records Officer for action.

This Freedom Of Information Request was based on the following
information:

Name: Mr Jones
Address: See email request
Email: [FOI #17537 email]
Telephone:
Request Details: Dear Sir or Madam,

In response to FOI number 3645, you advised that 35 Westminster
Councillors have a free official parking permit. Of these 35
Councillors, 31 belong to the Conservative party. In FOI number
4148 (being an extension to FOI 3933), you advised that 13
Conservative Councillors have purchased a resident parking permit.

I can therefore assume that 18 Conservative Councillors may have a
free official parking permit and have not purchased a resident
parking permit to park their car, outside their official working
hours.

Can you please advise on what basis these 18 Conservative
Councillors park their car in the streets of Westminster outside
their official working hours, given that in FOI 3934, you advised
that all 60 Councillors reside in Westminster, except two who
reside abroad (and are not on the list of Councillors who have a
free official parking permit, per FOI 3645)?

Yours faithfully,

FOI Reference Number: 4311
Target Completion Date: 29/09/2009

Please do not reply to this email.
This is an automatic response to your request, and replies to this message
will not be actioned.

If you need to contact Westminster City Council regarding your request,
please contact:

mailto:[Westminster City Council request email]
Tel:020 7641 3921

show quoted sections

Link to this

From: Craddock, Sarah
Westminster City Council

23 September 2009

Dear Mr Jones

Please find attached the response to your FOI.

As motorists, Councillors have the same right to use the highway as any
other motorist, both within and outside the hours when parking is
controlled. They are subject to the same statutory procedures if they
contravene parking regulations. How and what arrangements Councillors
have for parking when not on official business is a private matter for
Councillors as motorists and is not the subject of Council record.
Councillors are aware of their responsibility to ensure that permits are
only used for official business, and if misused this affects the integrity
of the Council.

Kind regards

Sarah

Sarah Craddock
Senior Committee and Scrutiny Officer
Department of Legal and Administrative Services

Westminster City Council
15th Floor
City Hall
64 Victoria Street
London SW1E 6QP

Tel: 020 7641 2770
Fax: 020 7641 2040
[email address]
[1]www.westminster.gov.uk

show quoted sections

References

Visible links
1. file://www.westminster.gov.uk

Link to this

From: Mr Jones

23 September 2009

Dear Ms Craddock,

Many thanks for your response.

1. You advise in your response that "Councillors are aware of their
responsibility to ensure that permits are only used for official
business". Well, obviously not, otherwise the 18 Conservative
Councillors who have not bought a resident parking permit in their
private capacity would have made sure that they had purchased one
to comply with the parking regulations outside their official
working hours.

In the light of the above, can you please advise what internal
communication, if any, has been sent to Councillors to make them
aware that their free official parking permit cannot be used
outside their official working hours. Can I please have a copy of
any email, letter or memo sent to Westminster Councillors to
achieve this.

2. You advise in your response that a (free) official parking
permit, if misused, affects the integrity of the Council. Well, 18
Conservative Councillors seem to be misusing their free official
parking permit. Can you please advise whether, to date, any
correspondence such as email, letter, memo etc has been sent to
each of these 18 Conservative Councillors to make them aware that
any misuse of their free official parking permit may affect the
integrity of the Council. Does the correspondence refer to any
action undertaken by the Council should the Councillors continue to
use their free official parking permit outside their official
working hours?

Yours sincerely,

Mr Jones

Link to this

From: Craddock, Sarah
Westminster City Council

25 September 2009


Attachment Parking Permit Application Form.2009.doc
47K Download View as HTML


Dear Mr Jones

Thank you for your email

Please find attached the Parking Permit Form which includes the Guidance
Notes on how the permit should be used. This form (with the guidance
notes) is sent to the Councillors firstly when they request to apply for
an official permit and again when the permit is issued to them.
Councillors have to renew their official parking permit every year and
each year they are issued with the Guidance Notes twice as stated above.
This requirement is set out in the Council's Code of Governance.

Please note that point 2 of the Guidance Note specifically states:

'An Official Parking Permit does not remove the need to purchase a
Resident's Parking Permit for the Members' Zone of residence (where
applicable), which must be displayed when the vehicle is parked near the
Members Home. Members who need to purchase a Residents Parking Permit
for their private use, should therefore continue to display this permit
in the normal fashion'.

Not all residents, with cars in Westminster need a residents parking
permit as they may, for example, have off street parking or other
arrangements. The Council does not monitor this and has no requirement
to do so.

Yours sincerely

Sarah Craddock

show quoted sections

Link to this

Ben Tweedy left an annotation (25 September 2009)

If they don't want the council's integrity to be affected, then shouldn't they want to monitor how their councilors use their permits?

Link to this

From: Mr Jones

25 September 2009

Dear Ms Craddock,

Many thanks for your prompt reply, which is much appreciated.

I have one more question: since the Council is keen to preserve its
integrity, by making sure that Councillors use their free official
parking permit during their official working hours only, please can
you advise what control(s) is/are in place to ensure that
Councillors do not use their official parking permit outside of
their official working hours.

Yours sincerely,

Mr Jones

Link to this

From: Craddock, Sarah
Westminster City Council

30 September 2009

Dear Mr Jones

Thank you for your email.

Members official duties are not confined to normal working hours. It
would be very difficult for parking enforcement officers to monitor this
in any practicable way. Members are fully aware of the rules relating
to the use of these permits and any misuse is likely to be regarded as a
breach of the Members Code of Conduct.

Best Wishes

Sarah

show quoted sections

Link to this

From: Mr Jones

30 September 2009

Dear Sarah,

Thanks for confirming what I was suspecting. The Council fully
trusts its Councillors, although 18 of them have not purchased a
resident parking permit to park and seem to be using their free
official parking permit 24/7. The fact that none of them has
received a single PCN since 1st January 2009 suggests that they
have been using their free official parking permit 24/7, otherwise
they would have no doubt received at last one PCN outside their
official working hours.

How can these Conservative individuals be trusted by their own
residents, given that they can't follow the rules of their own
council? Perhaps the council should think about introducing
controls to avoid the (delibarate) mis-use of the Councillor's free
official parking permit.

Yours sincerely,

Mr Jones

Link to this

Things to do with this request

Anyone:
Westminster City Council only: