RESPONSES TO THE CONSULTATION ON THE DRAFT STRATEGIC HOUSING LAND ASSESSMENT

RESPONSES TO THE CONSULTATION ON THE DRAFT STRATEGIC HOUSING LAND ASSESSMENT

MARSKE

Site Number	Respondents (list)	Summary of comments made (list to avoid duplication)
GENERAL	Marske Residents Association Marske Community Partnership St. Mark's Parochial Church Council Trevor Hewison Neil and Lesley Jones Sally A Howe Cllr Deborah Dowson Mr & Mrs Sanderson and other residents Joan Williams Jennifer Tranter Susan Sharpe Mrs TM Hutton Michelle Tranter Mrs Sarah Maddison Pippa Maddison Bill Porritt John and Maureen Graham Christopher Tranter Gillian Simpson John Libbey Philip Miles Mrs GB Mr J Else Andrew Fox Alastair MacKenzie Catherine MacKenzie Alan Stevenson Catherine Lince Maggie Gee CR Walkington Mr PA Galloway Raymond Hutton Mr and Mrs Fox Steve Graham Robin Lockhart Mr and Mrs Lord Mrs PM Keeons David Cummins Marske Against Development Michael Beever J Bishop & J Colley Mr R Bruce A&G Walker Mr S Haining Mrs Valerie Early P Phillips Mrs S Bennett B Wanies Mrs Gael Dick L McFaull Robert Thirkell Alwyne & Angela Durham Mrs TJ Porter Kevin Bain Brian G Ridsdale James Cooper Steve Thompson Graeme Heslehurst Carole Sanders Kevin A Drury Andrea Lojko Mr J Goodwill	Why has the subject of further building in and around Marske come up again when a Government inspector advised against it? Object to development in the area - loss of green space/loss of strategic gap/visual impact/impact on facilities and infrastructure/sustainability/congestion/scale of proposal/impact on services/impact on wildlife Objects to any future development in Marske.
OFFICER RESPONSE:

MARSKE

Site Number	Respondents (list)	Summary of comments made (list to avoid duplication)
8	St. Mark's Parochial Church Council David Evans	Development of this site is a contradiction of the Structure Plan/Council's own Local Plan. Development of this site would erode the strategic gap between Marske and Saltburn.
10	St. Mark's Parochial Church Council David Evans	Development of this site is a contradiction of the Structure Plan/Council's own Local Plan. Development of this site would erode the strategic gap between Marske and Saltburn.
13	Signet Planning on behalf of Gladedale (Northern) Ltd	Would represent an unsuitable extension of the existing settlement and effectively double the size of New Marske. This would be contrary to national policy which seeks to protect the identity and character of settlements. The settlement would have to be able to offer a significant increase in the full range of services, including schools, jobs, shops, infrastructure etc. A more sustainable means of promoting this scale of development would be adjoining larger settlements which benefit from the existing infrastructure and services to accommodate development of this scale.
14	Phillip Phillips St. Mark's Parochial Church Council Mrs June Maloney Neil and Lesley Jones Mrs Sylvia Unthank Mr Fred Hartley Mrs Sylvia Unthank Kenneth Mothersill Mrs Sheila Shields Anna Unthank and Paul McLean Mr Charlie Nettle Mrs Patricia Wood David Nicholson Wendy Jarvis & Family Alison Blower David Evans Margaret Cummins Betty Addison Pat Matthews Gerry McBride Debbie Matthews Lynne Coleman Bill Goodwill Marguerite Ina Hesp Sheila Alker David Alker Barbara and Gerome Anne W Lowe Glenn Brunskill Laura and Andrew Waggett Dennis and Margaret Stanley H Gelder Mrs A Gelder J Armstrong Miss R Hainsworth Dennis and Margaret Stanley A Johnson Mrs Sylvia Unthank Anna Unthank and Paul McLean Mrs June Maloney Miss R Hainsworth Richard Graham Mr J Wollaston	Objects to any building on this land. Concern regarding proximity to cliffs, any development will be visible from Redcar. Concern over erosion of cliffs. Objects - loss of Greenfield area/effect on environment/effect on wildlife/congestion/effect on local services - schools etc/coastal erosion Objects - this land was a gift from Lord Zetland and there is in existence a covenant which limits the use of the land to agricultural purposes including buildings. Objects - does not want to live near to a building site for years.
21	St. Mark's Parochial Church Council	Concern regarding school and loss of playing field.
54	Cllr Denis DJ Sewell St. Mark's Parochial Church Council David Evans Nathaniel Lichfield and Partners Richard Murphy	The need for housing in the green belt (slice) is more exact i.e. between quarry roundabout and so policy is regarded with grave reservations. Contradiction of the Structure Plan/Council's own Local Plan. Development of this site would erode the strategic gap between Marske and Saltburn. This site represents the most sustainable site in Marske. The development of the site would not result in the coalescence of the two settlements which would remain physically separated by the A174 and a large area of undeveloped land. A sensitive design, layout and landscaping could also enhance the perception of separation ensuring that the separate identities of both settlements are maintained. Subject to further investigation there could be scope for a financial contribution to increase the capacity of the local sewerage infrastructure commensurate to the need arising from the new housing development. Site is accessible by public transport. An assessment of the highways implications has determined that an acceptable vehicular access can be achieved. Subject to further investigation there could be scope for a financial contribution to increase capacity at local schools commensurate to the need arising from the development. A preliminary Archaeological Assessment has been prepared which confirms that, subject to more detailed investigations, there is no evidence that the development is likely to be constrained by archaeological remains within the site. Design and layout of the scheme could satisfactorily address the impact of power lines on the site. Objects - loss of Greenfield and scenery.
55	St. Mark's Parochial Church Council David Evans Mr J Wollaston Anne W Lowe	Contradiction of the Structure Plan/Council's own Local Plan. Development of this site would erode the strategic gap between Marske and Saltburn. Objects - does not want to live near to a building site for years. Objects - devalue of community, loss of strategic gap, loss of green belt.
56	St. Mark's Parochial Church Council Alastair McLeod Wendy Jarvis & Family Margaret Cummins Betty Addison Pat Matthews Gerry McBride Debbie Matthews Lynne Coleman Bill Goodwill Marguerite Ina Hesp Sheila Alker David Alker Barbara and Gerome Anne W Lowe Laura and Andrew Waggett KW Cook J Armstrong Ronald Gosling Sally A Howe Paul and Caroline Robertson David Evans Mr J Wollaston	Contradiction of the Structure Plan/Council's own Local Plan. Objects - effect on countryside/transport/local services/infrastructure/environment/loss of green belt/access to site Requires a transport link. Development on this site would decrease the value of her property. Objects - site has been identified as a Sensitive Landscape Area, it is outside of development limits, it falls within the Teesside Agglomeration for Noise Mapping due to start in Summer 2008, concerns over water supply, effect on sewerage system, the land is also a recreational area. Development of the site would erode the strategic gap between Marske and Saltburn, also highlights concern with increase in traffic and access to the site. Objects - does not want to live near to a building site for years.
57	David Evans	Development of this site would erode the strategic gap between Marske and Saltburn.
77	David Evans	Development of this site would erode the strategic gap between Marske and Saltburn.
216	Ronald Gosling Margaret Cummins Betty Addison Pat Matthews Gerry McBride Debbie Matthews Lynne Coleman Bill Goodwill Marguerite Ina Hesp Sheila Alker David Alker Barbara and Gerome	This site includes our factory (HW Jarvis), a major employer in the area, housing development provides us with an opportunity to bid for provision to developers, an opportunity that won't exist if we don't. Land clean up would be required on this site. Objects - effect on countryside/transport/local services/infrastructure/environment.