This is an HTML version of an attachment to the Freedom of Information request 'Infection Prevention and Control Audit'.

0x01 graphic

DRAFT

Quality, Standards and Effectiveness Directorate

Infection Prevention and Control Audit Report

(General Practice)

Audits undertaken between September 2008-November 2008 by

Patricia Cross/Andrea Caldwell

Community Infection Prevention and Control Nurses

Compiled by:

Anne Warburton

Quality Facilitator

North Lancashire Teaching Primary Care Trust

Key: this page to be removed before issue to practices

ID

Practice

L1

Westgate Medical Centre

L2

Scale Hall

L3

Hambleton Practice Branch

L4

Great Eccleston

L5

Holland House

L6

Broadway Medical Centre

L7

Ansdell

L8

Over Wyre Medical Centre

L9

Carleton Practice

L10

Strawberry Gardens

L11

Moor St Kirkham

L12

Queen Square Lancaster

L13

Bailrigg

L14

Dalton Square

L15

Silverdale Surgery

L16

Halton Practice

L17

Old Links Practice St Annes

L18

Lockwood Ave Poulton

L19

Thornton Practice Church Road Thornton

L20

Dr Kwun Fleetwood

L21

Bolton le Sands

L22

Ashtrees Carnforth

L23

King St

L24

Westend Morecambe

L25

Meadowside Lancaster

L26

Dr Ali Fleetwood

L27

Clifton Drive Surgery

L28

Park Road St Annes

L29

Derbe Rd

L30

Queensway Poulton

L31

Belle Vue

L32

Owen Road

L33

Morecambe Medical Centre

L34

Heysham Medical Centre

L35

As Tree House Kirkham

L36

Mountview Fleetwood

L37

Rosebank Lancaster

L38

Caton

L39

Fernbank St Annes

L40

Yorkbridge Morecambe

L41

Poplar House St Annes

L42

Crescent Surgery Cleveleys

L43

Village Practice Thornton

L44

Landscape Surgery Garstang

L45

Cleveleys Group Practice

L46

Galgate Highland Brow

L47

Winsdor Surgery Garstang

Contents

Introduction

The Department of Health is firmly committed to reducing healthcare associated infections (HCAI). To bring about an improvement in infection prevention practice it is important that measures known to be effective in reducing infection are rigorously and consistently applied, and are embedded into everyday practice. The Health Act 2006: Code of Practice for the prevention and control of healthcare associated infections indicates that compliance with audit programmes will provide assurance that demonstrates infection prevention and control is an integral part of the practice culture.

Aim

The aim of this audit programme was to give a clear indication of the standards of infection prevention and control and the environment within the institution. The audit tools used have been specifically designed by the Infection Control Nurses Association to monitor infection prevention and control within community settings.

Method

Community Infection Prevention and Control Nurses Patricia Cross and Andrea Caldwell carried out the audits. The audit programme started in September 2008 and was completed in December 2008.

All 39 GP practices within the geographical area of NHS North Lancs were invited to take part. 1 Practice declined due to the recent death of a partner and subsequent building changes that were envisaged to last approximately 3 months.

The Infection Prevention Control Nurses visited 38 practices and14 branch practices and were assisted by practice nurses and practice managers on all visits. Once the information had been analysed each practice was then sent a report that highlighted the issues that need to be addressed. Other supporting literature e.g. policies, posters and national guidance was also sent. Each practice was also asked to submit a detailed action plan that demonstrated how changes could be implemented.

This audit programme has examined the following standards:

Environment : The environment will be maintained appropriately to reduce the risk of cross infection.

Hand Hygiene: Hands will be decontaminated correctly and in a timely manner using a cleansing agent to reduce the risk of cross infection.

Personal and Protective Equipment: Personal protective equipment is available and is used appropriately to reduce the risk of cross infection.

Sharps Handling and Disposal: Sharps/ needlestick injuries, bites and splashes involving blood or other body fluids are managed in away that reduces the risk of injury or infection.

Vaccine transport and storage: Vaccines are stored and transported safely.

Summary of Results

%

Practice

Environment

Hand Hygiene

Personal & Protective Equipment

Sharps Handling

Vaccine Transport & Storage

Mean Average

L31

94

91

100

100

100

97

L12

90

92

100

96

100

96

L13

91

96

100

96

89

94

L7

81

92

100

96

95

93

L11

83

83

100

92

100

92

L38

83

88

93

100

95

92

L42

94

83

100

100

84

92

L46

77

88

100

100

95

92

L29

93

88

100

88

84

91

L23

87

88

94

96

89

91

L3

80

83

94

96

100

91

L36

93

76

94

96

95

91

L26

91

88

94

96

79

90

L37

79

87

100

100

84

90

L20

71

91

94

100

89

89

L39

81

82

100

96

84

89

L6

71

83

93

96

100

89

L14

88

83

100

92

79

88

L15

82

73

100

96

n/a

88

L2

90

88

81

92

89

88

L21

81

77

100

92

89

88

L22

77

83

95

92

95

88

L41

77

79

100

85

89

86

L5

62

83

94

92

95

85

L24

86

63

87

96

95

85

L16

86

83

100

92

58

84

L30

76

79

83

92

89

84

L40

83

74

81

96

84

84

L1

81

75

88

84

89

83

L10

83

71

75

92

95

83

L35

77

83

81

92

84

83

L9

71

79

95

88

84

83

L34

73

74

83

96

84

82

L4

67

75

94

81

95

82

L25

84

70

79

92

79

81

L32

84

73

94

92

63

81

L33

77

74

89

92

74

81

L8

82

68

81

92

83

81

L27

55

77

94

88

84

80

L43

75

63

82

96

79

79

L44

74

63

69

96

95

79

L47

73

63

81

88

89

79

L19

59

79

81

92

79

78

L45

63

67

81

85

79

75

L18

64

63

69

84

68

70

L28

70

67

63

85

63

70

L17

52

63

82

77

68

68

Summary of findings

The areas highlighted for attention and contributed to poor compliance with the standards were:

Environment

Hand hygiene

Sharps handling and disposal

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)

Vaccine Usage

Fridge used for items other than vaccines.

The top of the fridge was used as a storage area.

Some fridges were over stocked.

Conclusion and recommendations

As this was the first time that an Infection Prevention and Control audit programme had been undertaken within GP practices throughout the geographical area of NHS North Lancs no comparison can be made.

The Infection Prevention and Control Nurses were made welcome at all practices and it was reassuring to see that there was a keenness to make changes and raise standards.

During each audit verbal advice was given and this was followed up with an individual report to each practice that highlighted the areas that need to be improved.

Environment

To help improve cleaning standards within the practices each practice was given an audit tool to assist with the monitoring of cleanliness standards and information was also provided on detergent wipes which would help with the cleaning of equipment and the environment.

It was also recommended that when each practice undergoes a process of refurbishment they consult the IPC nurses who would be able to advise on room design, sink design, floorings and fabric covering for furniture.

It was also suggested that all linen (hand towels, sheets and pillow cases) be removed and blue roll and wipeable pillowcases used instead.

Lastly it was recommended that curtains be laundered on a regular basis.

Hand Hygiene

To help improve standards of hand hygiene the IPC nurses have provided posters, which should be displayed at all hand wash sinks. Each practice has also been offered hand hygiene training sessions and information on NPSA approved hand hygiene products.

Practices were also reminded that sink areas should be kept free from clutter and that nail brushes are single use items.

Sharps handling and disposal

To ensure sharp safety all Practices were advised that any containers that are not bar coded must be labelled with room name and date prior to collection. To ensure a safe position wherever possible containers should be wall mounted with appropriate brackets.

First aid posters have been provided to all Practices that did not have one on display.

Personal Protective Equipment

To help reduce clutter at the sink areas it was recommended that gloves are stored in cupboards or on trolleys a way from an area where they could get splashed and damp.

It was also recommended that each Practice have a supply of face masks which could be used if there was a risk of body fluid splashing and would also be part of pandemic flu planning.

Vaccine Usage

It was recommended that vaccine fridges store vaccines only, and are stocked to appropriate levels.

Action Plan

As part of the Audit Cycle, it is expected that an action plan is produced by each Practice outlining the recommendations, how this will be achieved, by whom and in what time frame. So far the IPC Nurses have received 27 action plans, which illustrate how the recommendations will be met. A polite reminder has been sent to the Practices where action plans are outstanding.

Each Practice has been provided with a copy of the audit tools and encouraged to carry out the audit on a 3-6 monthly basis. It is envisaged that this will help to maintain and hopefully improve standards and reduce the number of Practices receiving a minimally compliant score.

It is anticipated that the Infection Prevention and Control Nurses will re-audit the Practices on a bi- annual basis.

Overall Scores

Overall scores were calculated for each standard as follows:

For each section of the audit, the percentage of `yes' responses was calculated as

Number of `yes' responses x 100

`yes' responses + `no' responses

This calculation therefore excluded N/A responses, where the question was not applicable.

Standard

%Score

No of N/A questions

Environment

79

0

Hand Hygiene

79

0

Personal and Protective Equipment

90

0

Sharps Handling and Disposal

93

0

Vaccine Transport and Storage

86

0

Overall Score

85

0x01 graphic

The following table shows overall performance based on the mean average scores of all the standards.

0x01 graphic

Overall Individual Scores

The following table shows which practices achieved overall Compliance with the standards (75% - 100%).

ID

% Score

L31

97%

L12

96%

L13

94%

L7

93%

L42

92%

L46

92%

L38

92%

L11

92%

L29

91%

L23

91%

L36

91%

L3

91%

L37

90%

L26

90%

L20

89%

L6

89%

L39

89%

L22

88%

L14

88%

L21

88%

L2

88%

L15

88%

L41

86%

L5

85%

L24

85%

The following table shows which practices achieved Minimal Compliance with the standards (0% - 74%).

ID

% Score

L18

70%

L28

70%

L17

68%

Practices which achieved Partial Compliance have been audited but have not been shown.

Put number of practices here

Key:

Compliant (85% - 100%)

Minimal Compliance (0% - 74%)

0x01 graphic

Score

No of Practices

%

Compliant

25

54%

Partial Compliance

19

40%

Minimal Compliance

3

6%

Environment:

Standard: The environment will be maintained appropriately to reduce the risk of cross infection.

0x01 graphic

Score

No of Practices

%

Compliant

12

26%

Partial Compliance

21

44%

Minimal Compliance

14

30%

Hand Hygiene

Standard: Hands will be decontaminated correctly and in a timely manner using a cleansing agent to reduce the risk of cross infection.

0x01 graphic

Score

No of Practices

%

Compliant

12

26%

Partial Compliance

19

40%

Minimal Compliance

16

34%

Personal and Protective Equipment

Standard: Personal protective equipment is available and is used appropriately to reduce the risk of cross infection.

0x01 graphic

Score

No of Practices

%

Compliant

31

66%

Partial Compliance

13

28%

Minimal Compliance

3

6%

Sharps Handling and Disposal

Standard: Sharps/ needlestick injuries, bites and splashes involving blood or other body fluids are managed in a away that reduces the risk of injury or infection.

0x01 graphic

Score

No of Practices

%

Compliant

43

91%

Partial Compliance

4

9%

Minimal Compliance

0

6%

Vaccine Transport and Storage

Standard: Vaccines are stored and transported safely

0x01 graphic

Score

No of Practices

%

Compliant

24

52%

Partial Compliance

16

35%

Minimal Compliance

6

13%

NB: One practice does not have vaccine facilities and was not audited in this standard.

Appendix 1 - Audit Tool

1

C:\Documents and Settings\stokesr1\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\OLK171\GP 2008 Audit Report doc final draft (5).doc